The short answer
Repair when the lead is sound and the fault is local: a lifted edge, a failed joint in the wall, one short split. Replace when the sheet is cracked at several folds, thinned, or too far gone to take another dressing. The roof survey decides which, and you receive one written price.
When a repair is enough
A repair keeps the existing lead and puts right the fault that let water in. It makes sense where the sheet itself is in good order and the problem is at its edge or in what holds it. Each of the three below is a way of dealing with a fault, and none of them replaces the lead.
- Re-dressing: a lifted edge or corner is worked back flat onto the covering and held with a clip so the wind cannot get under it.
- Re-pointing: the top edge of the lead is tucked into a cut joint in the brickwork, and where the mortar around it has crumbled, the joint is raked out and refilled so the edge is gripped again.
- A patch over a single short split, formed in lead and secured at its edges, on a flashing that is otherwise sound.
These jobs depend on the lead still being workable. Old lead that has stayed supple can be bent back into position; lead that has been folded many times, or has gone brittle, will crack when moved. The lead is tested at the survey before any route is chosen. Our page on patching lead on a roof covers the small-split case in more depth.
When replacement is the better route
Replacement means stripping the old flashing and fitting new lead cut to the junction. It suits cases where a repair would only treat one symptom of a general problem.
Look to renewal where the sheet is split along several folds, where it has thinned until the surface beneath shows, where pieces were cut too long and keep opening, or where the code is too light for the detail. A repair also fails where the wall is at fault: if the brickwork at the junction is crumbling, a new flashing has nothing sound to grip, so the wall is mended first.
Re-covering is another trigger. A fresh covering alters the level at which lead meets it, so flashings against walls and chimneys are reviewed, and tired lead is renewed rather than dressed over new tiles. If the work means cutting into a party wall to insert a flashing, the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 lists that as work for which the adjoining owner must be given notice, at least two months ahead, so raise it with your neighbour while planning the job.
What published prices show for lead
What a lead job costs turns on how much lead there is, the length of run, the way onto the roof and the state of the brickwork, and the third-party figures below show the scale. In Checkatrade's repair table (June 2026) lead flashing repairs run £50 to £70 per metre (excluding VAT), a rate that should never be multiplied into a total for your roof.
| Job | Figure | Page date |
|---|---|---|
| Chimney lead flashing patch repair | typically around £200 | 22 September 2026 |
| Chimney lead, full replacement | averages around £570 | 22 September 2026 |
| Full leadwork replacement, range | £350 to £920 | 22 September 2026 |
MyJobQuote's figures cover chimney leadwork only, and it says the range turns largely on whether scaffolding is required. They are no guide for lead flat roofs, bay windows or valleys, and they are page averages, not a quote for your house. What we quote for your house is set after the survey. The lead flashing cost guide covers the cost side in more depth, including what moves a lead price up or down on a particular roof.
Getting the decision made
Both routes begin with someone looking at the roof, not with a guess from the ground. We survey the roof, check the lead, the pointing and the covering around it, and name the route that fits, along with anything else seen up there.
If the job needs scaffolding, it sits inside the quote you receive. Where a highway licence is involved for that scaffold, we arrange the licence with our scaffolder. A picture on WhatsApp is a fair first look for us, though lead can only really be judged by handling it.
The lead roofing and leadwork hub lists the other jobs that involve lead, and the page on mastic on lead flashing covers the sealant shortcut and why it is no substitute for either route above. Whichever route is chosen, the decision rests on what the lead is like in the hand, not on its age. A flashing that looks plain from below can be sound or can be spent, and the hand test settles it.


