The short answer
Lead is sheet metal shaped on the roof to suit the valley, while GRP is a glass-reinforced plastic trough made to a standard profile. Neither choice is right for every roof. The published lifespans measure different things, so the decision rests on the valley's angle, the covering beside it and the survey.
What each valley is made of
A valley gutter runs down the line where two slopes meet in an internal corner. Rain from both slopes pours into it, so it carries the combined run-off of both. A leak there can let in far more water than a slipped tile, which is why the lining is worth getting right.
A lead valley is cut from a roll of lead sheet and dressed into the valley by hand. Because the sheet is soft it can be shaped to the angle and the width of that particular roof, which is useful on an old building where nothing is quite square. A GRP valley is a trough of glass-reinforced plastic, moulded in a factory and delivered in lengths. It is a rigid shell, so it suits straight valleys of a standard shape, and it comes in a limited set of widths and colours.
Our guide to lead valley replacement goes through how a lead valley is relined, and the page on lead flashing alternatives covers other materials.
What the published lifespans say
No guide gives a lifespan for a GRP valley trough, and none gives one for a lead valley. The published figures describe nearby things, so they are set out with their labels attached, and none of them should be read as a promise.
| Source | What it describes | Figure as published |
|---|---|---|
| MyJobQuote | Correctly installed lead flashing | can last for over 80 years |
| HomeBuilding | A lead flat roof | 60-100 years |
| Less | Lead, as a flat roof covering | 50 to 100 years |
| HomeBuilding | GRP as a flat roof covering | 25-30 years |
| Less | GRP fibreglass as a flat roof covering | 25 to 40 years with minimal maintenance |
The GRP figures belong to a flat roof covering and not to a valley trough, so they say little about a moulded liner. Taken for what they are, they show lead and GRP being measured as different things, and the Less and HomeBuilding ranges differ from one another. Neither one says which material suits a particular valley.
What shortens each one
Lead splits when it is cut too long and cannot move, when it is fixed so tightly that it strains, or when it is the wrong code for the width of the valley. Leadworx lists lead sheet in codes 3 to 8 under BS EN 12588, and leaves the choice of code to the specification for each part of a roof. A valley takes a lot of water, so the code is one of the choices that deserves attention at the survey.
A GRP trough can crack where a ladder or a boot has landed on it, and its edges can lift when the fixings loosen or the tiles beside it slip. It cannot be reshaped on site in the way lead can, so a trough that does not fit the angle of the valley is a poor start. Neither list is a ranking. A valley that is straight, wide and shallow suits one material, and a short, steep or crooked one may suit the other. The tiles that meet the valley edge matter too, because a lining has to be wide enough to carry the flow beyond the cut tiles on each side.
- Lead: splits at folds, thin code in a wide valley, tight fixings
- GRP: cracks from impact, lifted edges, poor fit to an odd angle
- Either: blocked valleys where leaves and moss pile up and hold water
How the choice gets made
The decision starts with the roof in front of us. We look at the covering beside the valley, whether the valley is straight, the age and condition of the timbers underneath, and what the roof would look like if the work were done in one material or the other. On a listed building the choice can be restricted, because a change of material can affect the building's character and need listed building consent.
The MyJobQuote leadwork figures are for chimneys only, so they say nothing about valleys, and the guides do not price valleys by material, so the figure for yours is set after a survey. You receive a single written total, covering the valley and whatever else the survey says needs doing. Whether the old lining can stay, or has to come out completely, is decided only once the tiles beside it have been lifted and the boards beneath have been seen. Start from the lead roofing and leadwork hub if you want the whole picture of lead on a roof.


