Call 01493 277103

Slate roofing

Welsh or Spanish Slate?

Both Welsh and Spanish slate are natural stone, and both keep rain out for generations. They differ in origin, in colour and texture, in the lifespan a published source gives them and in how well they suit the roof you already have.

Get a written quote

Call 01493 277103WhatsApp us

Roofer battening a green tarpaulin over a damaged slate roof in rain

Two quarries, one stone type

Slate is a fine-grained rock that splits cleanly into thin sheets. That is true whether it is cut from a quarry in Wales or from one in Spain, and it is the reason the two look like cousins from the street. What separates them is the rock itself: the mineral content, the grain and the way the stone has been squeezed and heated over geological time differ from place to place.

Welsh slate comes from the quarries of North Wales and has roofed British buildings for a very long time. Spanish slate is imported, and it is the alternative that buyers look at when the budget will not stretch to Welsh. Both arrive on a pallet as finished slates, cut to a standard size, holed at the head and graded before they are sold.

Neither wins in every case. The fair comparison is between a particular slate from a particular quarry, with its own grade and thickness, and your roof. A thick, well-split slate from either country will outlast a thin one from the same country, and a poor roof built with excellent slate will still fail at the fixings. Our slate roofing hub covers the covering as a whole, and this guide narrows to the choice of stone.

It also helps to separate the stone from the roof. A slate is only one layer: the battens, the underlay, the fixings and the lead detailing carry equal weight in how long a roof lasts, and the survey checks each of them.

How they look on the roof

Colour is the first difference the eye picks up, and it is the one that decides whether a new slate will match an old one. Welsh slate runs through blue-grey and purple tones, with a surface that carries a slight sheen when wet. Spanish slate runs to a darker, flatter grey with an even tone from one slate to the next. These are broad descriptions only: a pallet from one quarry can differ from another, and weathering changes both over the years.

Texture and thickness matter on the slope too. Hand-split slate has a gently rippled surface that casts small shadows, and a thicker slate reads as a heavier, more solid roof from the pavement. A thinner, machine-cut slate lies flatter and looks crisper. Neither is a defect; they are different looks.

The only way to judge a match is to put the sample slate next to the old one, in daylight, wet and dry. Colour on a website or a sample card is only a rough guide. For a closer look at telling one from the other, our guide to reclaimed roof slates describes what the survey checks on a slate whose origin is not known.

Edge detail adds to the effect. Slates with a squared tail give a straight, formal course line, and dressed or rounded tails give a softer one. The choice is part of the design of the roof as much as the stone.

Broad differences in look

Welsh slate

  • Blue-grey to purple
  • Slight sheen when wet
  • Varies by quarry

Spanish slate

  • Darker, flatter grey
  • More even tone
  • Imported

Lifespan: what HomeBuilding publishes

Published lifespans for slate are approximate, and the source matters. HomeBuilding, in its guide last updated 30 September 2025, gives Welsh slate as 100+ years, Spanish natural slate as 75-100 years and reclaimed Welsh slate as 50-80 years. They are figures from one publisher, offered as approximate, and they are not a promise about any roof.

On those numbers Welsh slate is placed at the top of the range, but a slate is only as long-lived as what holds it. A Welsh slate held by iron nails will let go long before the stone is worn out, and a Spanish slate on sound battens with copper nails can still be in place when a neighbour's roof has been stripped twice. The stone and the fixings have to be considered together.

A reclaimed slate starts with years already used, which is why its range is shorter. If you are thinking of mixing reclaimed slates in, the guide to re-slating a roof shows where sorting and reuse fit into the job.

A longer-lived stone does not rescue a poor design either. The pitch has to suit the slate, the headlap has to be set for the exposure and the details at the ridge and verge have to be sound. A slate laid below its minimum pitch will leak in any grade.

Approximate lifespans, HomeBuilding

Welsh slate100+ years
Spanish natural slate75-100 years
Reclaimed Welsh slate50-80 years

HomeBuilding, last updated 30 September 2025. Approximate figures for the material, not a forecast for any one roof.

What each costs

Price is a reason to look at Spanish slate, though the two are not priced per square metre side by side in any figure cited here. HomeBuilding gives one worked comparison on a 65m2 roof over a standard three-bedroom semi. Plain concrete tiles may cost between £10,000 and £15,000 there, and Welsh slate for the same property might reach £18,000. It is one example from one publisher, with a stated roof size.

MyJobQuote's slate roof page (06/10/26) gives an average fitting cost of around £7,800, with no slate named. Which? Trusted Traders put replacing the whole roof of an average three-bedroom house at £7,000 to £21,000 excluding VAT (November 2025). The gap between figures is wide because the roofs behind them differ in size, access, detail and covering.

For your house, the price depends on the area, the number of valleys, abutments and chimneys, the scaffold needed and on any rot the survey uncovers beneath the old slates. It also depends on the stone you choose. What we send after the survey is one total, and it names the slate.

Remember that a quote for slate is a quote for a whole roof system. Battens, underlay, lead, ridge pieces and the labour of cutting slates around every valley and hip sit behind the headline figure, and two roofs of equal area can differ widely in what they involve.

Matching an existing roof

If a roof is being repaired, extended or part-renewed, the new slate has to sit beside the old. A mismatch reads from the road: a patch of a different grey, or a slate of a different thickness, shows up as a block. On a pair of semis or a terrace sharing one roof line, a patch that does not match shows against the neighbour's roof as well.

Matching begins with a sample slate and a visit. Colour, size, thickness and tail shape are compared against the roof, and the choice may be new slate from the same quarry, a close new equivalent or a reclaimed slate from the same stock. Reclaimed slate has the advantage of weathering already, so it blends from the first day.

Where only a few slates are replaced, the match is less critical, because a few new slates weather in within a few years. Where a whole slope is renewed beside an unrenewed one, the difference can last longer, and it is worth deciding whether to match the old slope or accept a visible join. Whichever it is, an extension needs its roof checked for pitch and exposure before the slate is chosen.

A short walk along the street helps here. Roofs of neighbouring houses show which colour and thickness have been used before, and how the slate has weathered after years in the open, which is a better guide than any catalogue.

Before you choose a slate

  • Hold a sample against the old slates in daylight
  • Check size, thickness and tail shape
  • Ask what grade and quarry the slate is
  • Check the roof pitch suits the slate
  • Ask the council about any conservation area rule

Size, pitch and fixings for either stone

Whichever stone is chosen, the roof has to suit it. Slate has a minimum pitch below which water is driven back up under the laps, and Cupa reads BS 5534 as allowing natural slate down to 20 degrees on a site of moderate exposure, laid as a 500 mm slate with a 115 mm overlap; a flatter roof falls outside that. A shallow lean-to or a low porch roof may fall below that, whatever the quarry.

Slate size affects both appearance and cost. Larger slates cover more area with fewer fixings, while smaller slates give a finer, more traditional course pattern and more joints. The right size is a design choice, balanced against the pitch and the exposure of the site, where fixings are calculated for the site's exposure under BS 5534.

Fixings are the same for both stones. Corrosion-resistant nails or hooks hold each slate, and the choice between them is covered in our guide to slate hooks or nails. Hook fixings, Cupa adds, are not for any slope under 25 degrees, so a low pitch narrows the options before the stone is even considered.

A slate supplier will give a grade and a thickness for each product. Ask for them in writing and compare like with like, because a thin, cheap slate from either country will not behave like a thick one.

Conservation areas and listed buildings

On a listed building, or under an Article 4 direction, the choice of slate is a consent question as well as a design one. Planning comes first: re-roofing a house is normally permitted development under Class C, though an Article 4 direction can take that away for a street. A listed building adds consent for work that touches the building's character. Whether an Article 4 direction applies to your address is a question for the council.

A council may look for like for like in these places: the same material, a close colour and a similar slate size and tail. A change from one natural slate to another can still count as a change of appearance. Check with Great Yarmouth Borough Council, or East Suffolk Council for Suffolk addresses, before ordering a slate, and ask whether the council wants to approve a sample.

In the Broads, the Broads Authority is the local planning authority for the part of a property inside its executive area, so the address settles who answers. Building Regulations remain with the district council's building control team or a registered building control approver. The planning and building-control route is checked with the council before work starts; our guide on re-slating a roof covers what the work involves once the slate is agreed.

Questions and answers

Is Welsh slate always better than Spanish slate?

No, not in every case. HomeBuilding gives approximate lifespans of 100+ years for Welsh slate and 75-100 years for Spanish natural slate, so Welsh is placed higher. Grade, thickness, fixings and the roof beneath matter as well, and a well-built Spanish slate roof outlasts a poorly fixed Welsh one. Ask for the grade and thickness of any slate offered, because those differ within each country as well as between them.

Can Welsh and Spanish slates be mixed on one roof?

They can sit on the same roof, but they will differ in colour and texture, and the join will show. It is better to put each on its own slope or its own roof than to blend them course by course. A sample held against the old slates shows how obvious the difference will be.

Which slate is cheaper?

Spanish slate is the choice buyers weigh when cost matters, but the two are not priced per square metre side by side in any figure cited here. HomeBuilding's example is a 65m2 three-bedroom semi where a Welsh slate roof might reach £18,000 (last updated 30 September 2025). Our quote after the survey is one total and names the slate. The survey is where a figure becomes specific to your roof.

Do I need permission to change the slate on my roof?

Re-roofing a house is normally permitted development under Class C, so a house may need no application. A conservation area with an Article 4 direction, or a listed building, can change that. Put the question to the council before ordering, and the council is asked before work starts. Listed buildings and conservation areas are the cases to raise first.

Get a written quote

Tell us about your roof

Hand dressing a lead ridge roll with a wooden bossing stick

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing

Call WhatsApp Written quote