Two ways to hold a slate
The traditional method is nailing. Two nails go through holes punched near the head of the slate and into the batten, and the course above covers them, so nothing shows from the ground. It has been the standard way to fix slate for as long as slate has been used for roofing, and it still is.
A hook fixing does the job differently. A strip of corrosion-resistant metal is fixed to the batten and bent into a hook that grips the tail of the slate from beneath, so the slate hangs by its bottom edge and is clipped in place. It needs no hole at the head, so the slate can be a plain cut piece of stone, and no nail is left to corrode inside the roof.
Neither method is a shortcut. Both fall under BS 5534, the slating and tiling standard, which BSI lists as BS 5534:2014+A2:2018. Marley points out that installing to BS 5534 isn't required by law, so the standard guides the work without being a statute, and a fixing specification is worked out for each roof. Each has a history. Nails have decades of proven use on roofs that survive, and hooks arrived later as a way to solve particular problems: slates with no usable head hole, and roofs where nails could not be driven cleanly. Both are in current use, and a good roofer will describe both before suggesting one.
Our guide to slate roofing puts the choice in the wider context of the whole covering. Here the focus is the fixing alone, and when each one is the right answer.
The pitch limit on hooks
Pitch is where the two methods part company. Cupa, a slate supplier, states that "hook fixings should not be used on any pitch below 25º". On a roof flatter than that, the slate sits at too shallow an angle for a clip at the tail to hold it securely, and nails through the head are the answer.
That limit sits just above the roof's own minimum. Cupa puts the BS 5534 floor for natural slate at 20 degrees where exposure is moderate, assuming a 500 mm slate and a 115 mm overlap. So between 20 and 25 degrees a roof can be slated but must be nailed, and above 25 degrees both methods are open.
Check the pitch before you set your heart on either. A porch roof, a low lean-to or the shallow upper section of a mansard can fall below 25 degrees, and a main roof may be steeper or not. The survey takes the angle off each slope, and the fixing follows from the reading.
Exposure comes into the decision as well. Marley adds that a specification written for the individual site takes over from the BS 5534 minimums, weighing matters such as how exposed the roof is. Around Great Yarmouth that means fixings are calculated for the site's exposure under BS 5534, and the specification is what sets the number and type of fixings per slate.
Where each fixing applies
Hooks
- Pitch 25 degrees or above
- Clipped at the tail
- No head holes
Nails
- Any workable pitch
- Through the head
- Hidden by course above
Copper and aluminium nails
Nails are not all the same, and the metal is what matters. Ordinary iron or steel nails rust, and the rust is behind the slates that slip, as our guide to nail fatigue in slate roofs. A new roof is fixed with nails that cannot rust: copper, aluminium or an equivalent.
Copper is the traditional choice. It is soft, bright when new and darkens to a dull brown, and it does not corrode in the damp conditions under a slate. Aluminium is lighter and is also used, and it must be kept clear of metals it reacts with. The specification names the metal, the length and the gauge of the nail for the slate and the batten.
Length matters because a nail has to pass through the slate, any underlay and into the batten with enough grip. A nail driven too hard cracks the slate, and one left proud lifts the slate above it so that it sits off the course. A well-driven nail has its head snug against the stone.
Where a nail goes in also matters. For a slate with a head hole it goes through the hole, and for one with a hole too close to the edge or already broken, it does not hold. That is the point at which a hook can rescue a slate that nails cannot hold, which is a reason hooks are used on repairs and reclaimed slates. Stainless steel is a third option in some specifications. Its price is higher per fixing, but the cost is small against the labour of laying the roof, and it does not corrode.
What a fixing specification names
- The metal: copper, aluminium or equivalent
- The nail length and gauge
- The number of fixings per slate
- Whether hooks are used, and on which slopes
- How cut slates are held at hips and verges
How each looks on the roof
Nailed slate is the plainer roof to look at. The nails are covered by the course above, so the slope is an unbroken run of slate tails with a clean line. It is the picture that comes to mind with the words slate roof.
A hook fixing is visible if you look for it. The clip gripping the tail shows as a thin dark line or small hook at the edge of the slate, and from the ground it is barely noticeable. Close up it is a different look from the traditional course line, and on a roof whose age is part of its look, a visible clip can read as a modern detail.
Whether that matters depends on the roof. On a back slope that nobody sees from the road, it hardly matters at all. On the front of a period house it may matter a great deal, particularly in a conservation area, where appearance carries weight. The colour of the hook can be chosen to blend with the slate, and the difference is small, but it is real.
Mixing methods on one roof is possible. Where a main slope is nailed and a shallow porch roof must be nailed too, the two match. Where a slate has a broken head hole, a hook on that one slate leaves the rest of the course as it was.
Fixings in conservation areas and listed homes
If your home is in a conservation area or is listed, the fixing is a question for the council. Under Class C, re-roofing a house is normally permitted development, but an Article 4 direction can withdraw that for a street, and listed building consent is required where work would alter what gives a listed building its character. A change from nails to hooks alters the look of the tail slightly, so ask the council about it.
Put two questions to the council: whether an Article 4 direction covers your address, and whether it wants to see the fixing along with the slate. For addresses in the Great Yarmouth borough that is Great Yarmouth Borough Council, and for Suffolk addresses it is East Suffolk Council. Inside the Broads executive area, planning is decided by the Broads Authority, and the address settles which body you ask.
A council that wants like for like in these places may have a view on the fixing as well as the stone, so do not assume. The council is asked about planning before work starts, and the question of fixings goes in with it.
Nothing here changes the Building Regulations side. Building control is asked as well, because recovering the whole slope passes the 50 per cent of the roof set in the Planning Portal's no-application test.
Myth
Hook fixings are allowed on any natural slate roof.
Fact
Cupa advises against hooks below 25 degrees, and a council may have a view in conservation areas.
Cut slates, edges and awkward corners
The field of the roof is the easy part for either fixing. Trouble starts where slates are cut: along a hip, into a valley, at a verge and around a chimney or roof window. A cut slate may lose its head holes altogether, and it has to be held some other way.
That is where hooks and clips earn their place. A cut slate with no hole can be held at the tail or by a clip made for the purpose, and the rest of the roof stays nailed. A roof with many changes of plane has a lot of cut slates, and the number of special fixings rises with it.
The edges bring their own point. At a verge or an eaves, the wind lifts the tail of a slate first, so these slates are fixed more firmly than the field. The specification sets how many fixings go in, and the extra ones are a matter of exposure, not of style.
Ridge and hip pieces are a separate system again. They are held by dry-fixed fittings covered by BS 8612:2018, not by the slate nails. Asking for the whole fixing plan, from the field to the ridge, shows whether a roofer has thought it through.
Which one for your roof
Start with the pitch. Under 25 degrees, nails are the only option. At 25 degrees or more, both are open, and the choice turns on the roof itself: how exposed it is, what the slates are like and what the council expects.
Nails suit whole-roof jobs on new or sound slate, because they leave the cleanest line and the fixing is hidden. Hooks suit slates whose head holes are damaged, reclaimed slate that has been through a lot, and jobs where a fixing without a hole at the head is preferred. Our guide to reclaimed roof slates shows where worn holes come into the picture.
Cost follows the whole job, not the fixing alone. On MyJobQuote's 06/10/26 page a whole slate roof averages around £7,800 to fit, a figure that does not split out the fixing. Our quote is one written total price after a survey, and it names the fixing used.
Whichever you choose, the fixing must resist corrosion and be sized for the slate, the batten and the site. It determines how long the roof keeps its slates, and the survey and the specification fix it down. A short question to put to any roofer is which fixing is being specified and why. The answer should name the metal, say whether hooks are in the plan and give the reason, and that reason should come back to the pitch and the condition of the slates.


