Call 01493 277103

Slate roofing

Reclaimed Roof Slates: Worth It?

Reclaimed slates are second-hand slates salvaged from other roofs and sold for reuse. They can match an old roof better than any new slate, but only the sound ones are worth laying, and sorting them is where the value is won or lost.

Get a written quote

Call 01493 277103WhatsApp us

Cracked mortar under a ridge tile on a slate roof

What reclaimed slate is, and where it is used

A reclaimed slate is one that has already served on a roof. It was taken off a building that was stripped or demolished, cleaned of its old fixings, sorted and sold on. The stone is the same natural slate as a new one, and it has simply been through years of weather already.

Two reasons draw people to it. The first is looks: a slate that has weathered for decades has a softened colour and a surface texture that new slate takes years to reach, so a repair or an extension beside an old roof blends in from the first day. The second is the stone itself. Some old slate came from quarries that no longer supply, so a matching new slate may not exist.

Cost is the third reason people raise, and it should be treated with care. Reclaimed slate is not priced against new slate in any figure cited here, so the saving is not a number we can give. Reclaimed slate costs time as well as money, because the pile must be sorted, and slates that fail the checks are rejected. What you save on the slate can be spent on sorting and on replacing the ones that do not pass.

The wider picture of the covering sits in our slate roofing hub. This guide deals with the specific question of whether to put used slate on a roof, and how to tell a good batch from a poor one.

Grading: how a batch is sorted

Reclaimed slate is sold by size and by condition, and the grading is what you are paying for. A merchant sorts slates into lengths and widths, because a roof is laid in courses that reduce in length from eaves to ridge, and a batch of random sizes is hard to use. Slates are also sorted by thickness and by how sound they are.

Condition is where the judgement lies. A good reclaimed batch is made of slates that are flat, whole, free of splits and ring when tapped. A poorer batch has chipped tails, hairline cracks, thin and flaking slates and holes that have broken out. Grade names differ from one supplier to another, so ask what each grade means in plain terms rather than relying on the label.

Ask for a sample and look at it. Turn a few slates over and check the back as well as the face, because damage to the underside, such as a stain or a layered edge, tells you about the slate's history. Ask how many are to be allowed for rejects, since a stated number is more useful than a promise that every slate is perfect.

Quantity needs a margin. Some slates will fail on the roof when they are cut or fixed, and a few more will be needed for the cuts at hips, valleys and verges. The survey sets the area, and the margin is added to it.

Questions for a slate supplier

  • What sizes are in the batch, and how many of each?
  • How thick are the slates?
  • What do you grade out, and why?
  • How many rejects should I allow for?
  • Can I see a sample in daylight?

Nail holes, delamination and other checks

Two faults rule out a reclaimed slate: worn nail holes and delamination. A slate is fixed through holes near its head, and years of weather and a rusting nail enlarge the hole or crack the stone around it. A hole that has broken through to the edge will not hold a new nail. Some slates can be re-holed higher up, which shortens them and reduces the headlap, so the new hole has to leave enough overlap for the roof's pitch.

Delamination is the splitting of a slate into thin layers along its natural bedding. The signs are a flaking or powdery edge, a surface that peels in sheets and a dull thud rather than a clear ring when the slate is tapped. A delaminating slate absorbs water, swells and breaks, and it will not stop doing so on its new roof. The slate gets rejected, however good it looks from a distance.

A third check is for hairline cracks. Hold the slate up to the light and look along the line of the holes, which is where a crack can start. Tap each slate lightly: a sound slate rings, and a cracked one sounds flat.

Every slate has to pass these checks individually. HomeBuilding gives reclaimed Welsh slate approximate lifespan of 50-80 years against 100+ years for Welsh slate (last updated 30 September 2025), and a slate that has used part of that life must be sound for the rest of it. Our guide to re-slating a roof shows where the sorting happens in the job.

Myth

A reclaimed slate that looks good will last as long as a new one.

Fact

Looks hide worn holes and delamination; only a check slate by slate shows them.

Lifespan: what the published figure says

HomeBuilding, in its roof cost guide last updated 30 September 2025, gives approximate lifespans for natural slate: Welsh slate 100+ years, Spanish natural slate 75-100 years and reclaimed Welsh slate 50-80 years. The figures are approximate and they come from one publisher, so read them as a range, not a promise.

The reclaimed figure is lower because the slate has already spent part of its life. It does not mean a reclaimed roof fails at 50 years. It means the stone's remaining years are shorter, and where one roof sits inside that span depends on the slate in hand and on how hard its first life was.

Then there is the question of what holds the slate. A reclaimed slate on new battens, new underlay and corrosion-resistant fixings has a good base. The same slate on old, dry battens and rusting nails will slip long before the stone fails. When reclaimed slates are used, the roof beneath them has to be sound, and the survey looks over the whole structure to judge whether it is.

Weigh the two lifespans against the job. For a repair of a few slates on an old roof, reclaimed slate matching the originals is a sensible choice. For a full re-roof on a house you plan to keep for decades, a published range that starts at 50 years is worth weighing against new stone.

Published slate lifespans

Reclaimed Welsh

  • 50-80 years
  • Slate already used

Welsh, new

  • 100+ years
  • Approximate

Handling, storage and fixing reclaimed slates

Slate arrives on a pallet, and how it is stored matters. Slates should stand on their long edge, not stacked flat in a heap where the weight of the pile can crack the bottom ones. Keep them dry and off bare ground, because a slate that is already tired takes up water faster. Carry a few at a time, since a dropped slate does not survive.

Old fixings come off with the slates. Rusted iron nails are not reused, and the holes they leave are cleaned out before the slate is checked. Fixing a reclaimed slate follows the same rule as a new one: nails or hooks that will not corrode, set through sound holes or clipped at the tail. Our guide to slate hooks or nails explains how each works, and why a hook can be the answer where a head hole has gone.

Cutting reclaimed slate is harder than cutting new, because an old slate is more brittle and can split along a cut. Expect a higher loss at hips, valleys and verges, and allow for it in the quantity. The edge of a cut slate is also an open face of stone, so it is laid where it will not carry the whole run-off from the slope above.

Mixing reclaimed slate with new

Reclaimed and new slates can share a roof, but the way they are mixed decides how it looks. Scattering new slates among old across the same slope gives a patchwork of tones that weathers in over the years. Keeping each type to its own slope, or to its own distinct area, gives a clean join instead, and it suits a mix where the colours differ sharply.

Thickness and size have to be allowed for. Old slates can differ from new in thickness, and a thicker new slate beside a thinner old one sits slightly proud and casts a different shadow. Where the courses meet, the gauge is kept consistent, so the battens have to be set out for the sizes actually being laid.

On a repair, the sensible approach is to match the slate closest to what is there and place the replacements where they will blend, away from the most prominent slope. On a full re-slate, the old slates that pass the checks go back and new slates make up the numbers, so the finished roof is a blend.

If the roof is in a conservation area or is a listed building, mixing is a question for the council. Re-roofing a house is normally permitted development under Class C, but an Article 4 direction can change that, and listed building consent is needed for anything that affects the character of a listed building. Ask whether the council wants to see the slates first.

Is it worth it?

Reclaimed slate is worth considering in three cases. The first is a repair beside old slates, where a new slate would stand out. The second is a roof where the original slate is no longer made and a close match is hard to find. The third is a full re-slate where the roof's own sound slates can go back, because that is reclaimed slate in its simplest form.

It is a poorer choice where the roof will be stripped and relaid on a tight budget with a batch of unknown condition, or where the pitch is shallow and a re-holed slate would lose too much headlap. A new slate with a stated grade can be the more reliable purchase there, and its price is clear.

The cost of fitting is separate from the price of the slate. MyJobQuote's page for slate roofs (06/10/26) averages the fitting cost at around £7,800, a figure for slate in general. Pricing for your roof follows a survey, and what we send you is one total.

A fair answer is that reclaimed slate is worth it when the old roof's character matters, the batch passes the checks and the roof beneath is sound. When any of those three fails, new slate is the cleaner path.

Questions and answers

Can the slates already on my roof be reused?

Some of them, yes. Each one is checked as it comes off for cracks, worn nail holes and delamination, and those that pass go back on. The number cannot be known until the slope is stripped. Slates that fail are replaced with new or reclaimed ones, and the written quote follows the survey.

How long do reclaimed slates last?

In a guide last updated 30 September 2025, HomeBuilding lists reclaimed Welsh slate at approximately 50-80 years, where Welsh slate is 100+ and Spanish natural slate 75-100. The range is a published approximation, not a promise, and it depends on how sound each slate and the roof beneath it are.

What is delamination?

It is a slate splitting into thin layers along its natural bedding. A delaminating slate has a flaking, powdery edge, peels in sheets and gives a dull sound when tapped. It soaks up water and breaks, so it is rejected whatever its face looks like. It is the main reason slates are graded out of a reclaimed batch.

Is reclaimed slate cheaper than new?

The two are not priced against each other in any figure cited here, so a saving cannot be promised. Reclaimed slate costs time in sorting and allows for rejects. What can be said is that it suits repairs and matching, and our written quote for your roof gives a single total after a survey.

Get a written quote

Tell us about your roof

Hand dressing a lead ridge roll with a wooden bossing stick

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing

Call WhatsApp Written quote