The short answer
Choose the underlay and the roof space together, because each decides the other. A high-resistance underlay holds vapour back, so in a cold roof Marley gives 25mm of eaves ventilation at 15 degrees or less and 10mm above 15 degrees.
What the underlay does under slate
Slates are laid in overlapping courses on timber battens, and the underlay is the sheet that runs across the rafters beneath those battens. Wind can push fine rain and snow through the joints between slates. The sheet catches whatever gets in and carries it down the slope to the eaves, where it drains into the gutter. It also leaves the house covered during a re-slate, once the old slates are off and before the new ones are on.
On an older roof the sheet may be missing altogether, or may have gone brittle. When a roof like that is stripped, a modern membrane goes on before the new battens, so the choice of underlay is a decision about the whole roof space and not only about one sheet.
A torn, sagging or perished underlay shows from the loft as daylight at the laps, wet or stained timber and rotted batten ends. The survey looks for those marks, and for the same reason an underlay that has been lifted with the slates is replaced and not put back.
High resistance or low resistance
The terms describe how freely a membrane lets water vapour through. A high-resistance (HR) underlay holds vapour back, and Marley treats it as not vapour-permeable. The low-resistance (LR) kind lets vapour pass, so the roof space has less to get rid of.
Marley's BS 5250 figures for a cold roof under an HR sheet are "25mm along the length of the eaves for pitches of 15° or less; 10mm along the length of the eaves for pitches of more than 15°." For an LR underlay beneath an air-permeable covering, Marley says the small gap that normal eaves construction leaves, about 3mm, is all that is required where UKAS third-party certification conditions are met. Ridge ventilation of 5mm is its alternative.
BSI lists BS 5250:2021, the code on moisture in buildings, as current but under review. Read the manufacturer's certificate for the membrane before choosing, because the wording on the roll's label does not show which side of the line it sits.
What each underlay asks of the roof
- HR: holds vapour back, so a cold roof needs eaves ventilation
- HR figure: 25mm at 15 degrees or less, 10mm above
- LR: lets vapour through, so less ventilation is called for
- Check the certificate, not the word breathable on the roll
Felt and breathable membranes
Bitumen felt has been laid under slate for a long time, and a roof that has stayed dry beneath it for decades shows the arrangement worked on that house. Newer membranes are sold as breathable. The word is used loosely, and it would be wrong to treat every sheet sold that way as low resistance. An HR sheet gets the eaves figures quoted earlier on this page, whatever the packaging says.
A warm roof, with the insulation at rafter level and no loft void under the slates, is ventilated on different rules from a cold roof, and the council's building control team can say which route suits the roof you have. Our re-slating a roof guide shows where the membrane sits in the order of work.
Pairing an LR sheet with a leaky ceiling, or an HR sheet with blocked eaves, is where condensation and rot begin, so both ends of the roof are looked at together when a roof is surveyed. Insulation pushed hard into the eaves, a box of stored belongings against the slope and painted-over eaves vents can each choke the airflow the underlay was chosen to rely on, and a membrane that is perfectly sound can still be blamed for damp that a blocked vent has caused.
What decides the choice on your roof
Four things set the choice, and they are weighed together. The pitch matters, because Marley's eaves figures change at 15 degrees. Whether the roof is cold or warm matters. So does the ceiling below, since a leaky ceiling pushes moist air up into the roof space. And the covering matters, because the LR route only works under an air-permeable covering.
If the slate is staying and only the underlay is in doubt, ask for the roof to be surveyed before anything is lifted. Our signs of a failing slate roof page explains what can be seen from outside, and slate roof repairs explained covers repairs that leave the underlay in place.
When Total Roofing Great Yarmouth surveys a slate roof, the underlay is checked from inside the loft and from the slope, and the figure that follows arrives as one written total price. The slate roofing hub lists the rest of the slate work.


