Call 01493 277103

Roof replacement

Signs You Need a New Roof

One leak is a repair; a pattern of faults across the roof points to replacement. This guide lists the signs that separate the two, with sourced lifespans and costs, as part of our roof replacement advice.

Get a written quote

Call 01493 277103WhatsApp us

A brick garage with a new grey membrane flat roof

Why the year it was laid is only a clue

A roof's age is a clue, not a verdict. Published lifespans are approximate and are given for coverings that were installed and looked after properly, and they say nothing about what has happened to your own roof since it went on. A roof that is well inside its published life can need replacing after a bad fault, while an older one may still be sound.

HomeBuilding's figures, on a page last updated on 30 September 2025, give approximate lifespans of 100+ years for Welsh slate, 60-80 years for clay tiles and 40-50 years for plain concrete tiles. Marley's page says "Typically, roof tiles are expected to last for around 60 years" and "This is not a guarantee or warranty of its longevity." For clay tiles specifically, the BRE determined a minimum life expectancy of 60 years, according to Marley. On concrete the two sources give different figures, which is why both appear.

What decides replacement is the condition across the whole roof. The question is whether the faults are local, such as a split valley or a loose ridge, or spread over every slope, which means the roof as a system is wearing out. A survey of the whole roof answers it, and our guide to what a new roof costs shows what a replacement involves in money.

Photographs help when you are deciding what to do. Pictures of the ridge, the eaves line and the loft taken in daylight now give you something to compare with next year's, and they show a firm what you have seen, which makes the conversation with any firm more precise, and a dated set of pictures is also useful if a claim or a dispute ever follows. The signs below are the ones a survey weighs together. One sign by itself may not settle it; two or three at once, spread over more than one slope, point towards replacement.

Signs the survey weighs together

  • Slipped or missing tiles on several slopes
  • Fixings that have corroded or worked loose
  • A sagging ridge, slope or eaves line
  • Torn, brittle or rotted underlay
  • Damp stains or wet timbers in the loft
  • Repairs that keep being needed in new places

Slipping tiles and fatigued fixings

A tile slips when what holds it fails. Nails corrode, clips lose their grip and timber battens split around the fixings. One slipped tile after a gale counts as a repair, and our guide to what a re-roof involves shows the alternative. Slipped tiles on several slopes, or tiles that keep dropping after each repair, mean the fixings across the roof are tired, and re-seating them one at a time does not cure that. Our guide to what a re-roof involves shows what the alternative looks like.

You can see some of the signs from the ground, in daylight and in dry weather: gaps in the courses, tiles sitting lower than their neighbours and fragments in the gutters or on the path. A pair of binoculars from a safe spot helps. Never climb onto a roof to check; tiles crack underfoot and the fall risk is real. A photo sent on WhatsApp also gives us something to look at without anyone going up.

Older fixing methods matter here. Marley records that the 2015 amendments to BS 5534 ended mortar as the only means of securing a roof covering that could be relied upon. Tiles on an older roof that were bedded and pointed in mortar alone may fall short of that today, and where the mortar has cracked and dropped away, little holds them.

A roof like that can be repaired in sections, but each section repaired leaves the next one to fail. At some point the cost of repeating the repair goes past the cost of dealing with the whole slope, and that point is a judgement for the survey to make.

Sagging, bowing and what the structure is telling you

A roof that has changed shape is giving a signal about the structure beneath. Look along the ridge from the end of the street: a ridge that dips, a slope that bellies inward or an eaves line that waves has lost its support somewhere. Causes include rotted rafters or wall plates, a covering heavier than the structure was built for, and timbers weakened by long-term damp.

Inside, the loft shows more. Stains on rafters, soft or crumbling timber, daylight where there should be none and wet insulation all point to water getting in over a long period. A dark, powdery patch spreading across the boards or the rafter ends is a prompt to get the roof looked at before the next wet spell.

Sagging is not something to patch. A structural engineer or surveyor can say whether the structure can carry a new covering like the old one. A covering 15 per cent or more heavier than the old one needs Building Regulations approval, so that check comes ahead of the choice of covering.

Where the sag is local, say over a single bay, the repair may be to the timbers and the covering above them. Where the whole roof bows, the structure and the covering are weighed together.

Failed underlay, damp lofts and moss

Underlay is the membrane under the battens. It is the roof's second line of defence, catching water that gets past the tiles. When it tears, becomes brittle or rots, wind-driven rain reaches the timbers directly, and no amount of tile repair stops it. A loft that is damp after rain, with no visible leak at any tile, is a sign to ask about the underlay.

Damp is not always a leak. Moist air from the house can condense on cold roof timbers if the roof space is not ventilated. Marley's ventilation figures for a cold roof laid with high-resistance underlay are 25 mm along the eaves at 15° or less and 10 mm above 15°, and it points out that such underlay is not vapour-permeable. A re-roof is the chance to put the ventilation right, so stained timbers with blocked eaves may call for more than patching.

Flashings deserve a look as well. Lead that has split or lifted, or has pulled away from a chimney or wall, lets water in at the junction, and MyJobQuote says correctly installed lead flashing can last for over 80 years, which makes a flashing that has failed early a question about how it was fitted. A failed flashing alone does not condemn a roof, but several failed details together add to the case. Moss and lichen are worth watching. They hold moisture against tiles and lift edges as they grow. Moss on its own is not a reason to replace; moss on tiles that are flaking and crumbling is part of a larger picture.

Spray foam sprayed under the slope can hide the timbers from view. If you have it, say so at the survey, since what lies behind it may need separate advice.

Repeat repairs and the money they add up to

A single repair is a sound answer to a single fault. A run of repairs in different places is another matter. If a new leak, a new patch and a new bill keep following one another, the roof is failing faster than it is being mended, and the sum of the repairs begins to close in on the cost of doing the job once.

Dated figures from other sources help with proportion, though none prices your roof, and a per-tile or per-roof figure from one source cannot be turned into a total for another. Which? Trusted Traders gave £75 to £400 for replacing a few broken tiles, from one to six, in November 2025, excluding VAT. On MyJobQuote's page of 6 October 2026, the average roof repair cost is around £650 in 2026. Set those beside the whole-roof range in our cost guide, where Which? gives £7,000 to £21,000 excluding VAT for an average three-bedroom house.

Keep the paperwork from any earlier repair, because it shows what was done and where, and the repair history is part of the case for or against replacement. The decision is not simple arithmetic. A repair that buys years without trouble is cheap, and one that buys a single winter is not. The survey can say which kind of repair your roof is facing. Our post on whether to repair or replace your roof sets out how that judgement goes.

A quote should help you compare. Ask for the reasons in plain words, and for the findings you can check against what you see from the ground. A firm proposing replacement should be able to say what it found that makes repair a poor choice, and a firm proposing repair should say what else it saw on the roof.

Myth

Every old roof needs replacing once it reaches a certain age.

Fact

Published lifespans are approximate; the condition of the whole roof decides, not the year it was laid.

Asbestos, insurance and what to do next

HSE's rule for a house built or refurbished before 2000 is that asbestos should be assumed present in it. A corrugated sheet roof on a garage or outbuilding may be asbestos cement, and HSE's own wording is that "AC roofs are always fragile". Nobody should walk on one. Whole sheets removed carefully count as non-licensed work, and the waste belongs in a lockable skip.

Insurance is a separate matter from age and wear. The Financial Ombudsman Service defines a storm in its own words: "Rain, hail or snowfall by itself can constitute a storm." Where a storm did the damage, take pictures before you move anything and tell your insurer. A roof that has simply worn out is not a storm claim.

The next step is booking a survey; you can also send a picture over WhatsApp for a first look. The survey covers the whole roof and not just the area that worried you, and you hear in plain terms what turned up. If the scaffold would obstruct the pavement or road, the county council issues the highway licence, and we arrange the licence with our scaffolder.

If the answer is replacement, our guide to Building Regulations for re-roofing explains what must be notified before work starts.

Questions and answers

Is my roof past repair, or can it be mended?

Look at how widespread the faults are. One slipped tile or a split valley is a repair. Slipping tiles on several slopes, a sagging ridge, damp timbers in the loft or repairs that keep being needed in new places point towards replacement. Only a survey that covers every slope can settle it, and a photo sent on WhatsApp makes a useful starting point.

How long should a roof last?

HomeBuilding gives approximate lifespans of 100+ years for Welsh slate, 60-80 years for clay tiles and 40-50 years for plain concrete tiles. Marley's own figure for tiles is around 60 years, and it stresses that the figure promises nothing about any one roof. Your roof's condition decides, which no table of ages can show.

Is a sagging roof dangerous?

It can be. A change in the shape of a roof means the structure beneath has lost support somewhere, and the weight of the covering may be too much for it. Do not go up to look. Ask a surveyor or structural engineer to assess it, and keep people away from any area that looks distorted.

Will my insurance pay for a new roof?

Not for wear and tear. A policy that covers storm damage depends on a storm having caused the damage, and the Financial Ombudsman Service handles complaints about how insurers decide that, which is a different question from whether the roof is old. If a storm did it, take pictures before anything is moved, inform your insurer promptly, then ask exactly what the policy covers.

Get a written quote

Tell us about your roof

Hand dressing a lead ridge roll with a wooden bossing stick

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing

Call WhatsApp Written quote