Call 01493 277103

Roof replacement

Choosing the Covering for a New Roof

A new roof covering is chosen against the roof's pitch, the weight the timbers carry, the rules for your address and the budget, long before colour comes into it. This guide compares pantile, plain tile, concrete interlocking tile and natural slate on published figures.

Get a written quote

Call 01493 277103WhatsApp us

Roofer rolling out a new rubber membrane over fresh boards on a garage roof

What a covering has to do before it looks right

Choosing roof tiles for a re-roof starts with the house, not a showroom sample. The covering sheds rain, resists wind uplift and carries its own weight onto rafters that were sized for something specific. Whatever you pick has to suit the angle of your slopes, the loads those timbers can take and any planning layer that applies to your street.

Four questions narrow the field quickly. What is the pitch of each slope, measured rather than guessed? What does the new covering weigh per square metre against the old one? Does a conservation area, the Broads or a listing apply to the address? And what total is realistic for the size of roof? The first two are physical and the manufacturer's data sheet answers them. The third is a call to the council. The fourth comes from the survey.

The Planning Portal sets out when a re-roof needs Building Regulations approval. One trigger is a new covering material that "increases the weight of the roof covering by 15 per cent or more". Another is a covering whose behaviour in a fire would differ significantly from the existing one. Both turn on the product you choose, so the covering has to be settled while the quote is still being prepared.

Fixings belong in the choice too. Marley explains that the minimum fixing levels in BS 5534 always give way to a specification written for the site, and that location, meaning how exposed the roof is, is one of the factors in it. Two houses can take the same tile and still need different nailing patterns. That is also why a tile chosen from a brochure picture is only a starting point: the survey measures the slopes, and the maker's data sheet then confirms whether the product can go where you want it.

Pantiles: clay and concrete

A pantile is the single-lap tile with an S-shaped profile. It is made in both clay and concrete, and the two behave differently on a roof. Product names such as Canterbury and Anglia belong to Marley's ranges and say nothing about a place, so read the data sheet for the exact tile on the quote.

Take Sandtoft's clay Old English Pantile as one worked example. Its data sheet (version 1.1, April 2025) gives a minimum roof pitch of 30 degrees, a headlap of 75 mm, a fixed batten gauge of 290 mm and, as laid, a weight of 41.6 kg per m². Those four numbers decide whether it can go on your roof: the pitch has to be met on every slope, the gauge dictates where each batten is nailed and the weight feeds into the structural question below.

Pitch limits vary a great deal from one pantile to the next, and the gap between the lowest and highest published figure is wide. Marley lists 15 degrees as the minimum for its Lincoln clay pantile and 25 degrees for its concrete Anglia. A low slope that rules out one pantile may suit another, but a shallower roof also leaves less margin for error at the laps, so the data sheet is the place to check, not a rule of thumb.

What matters for your house is what is on it now and whether the new covering matches or deliberately changes that appearance.

Read on a pantile data sheet

  • Minimum roof pitch for the exact product
  • Headlap in millimetres
  • Batten spacing, and whether the gauge is fixed
  • Weight as laid, per square metre
  • Material: clay or concrete
  • Fixing pattern for ridge, hip and verge

Plain tiles and concrete interlocking tiles

Plain tiles are small, laid in overlapping courses and made in clay and in concrete. Each course hides the nail holes of the one below, so the roof is covered twice over at every point, and the small size lets them follow a curved or complex roof shape. Marley lists 35 degrees as the minimum pitch for its concrete Plain tile. A clay plain tile has its own figure, so the maker's sheet is the reference.

Concrete interlocking tiles are larger, lock into each other along their sides and cover more of the roof per tile. Marley's published minimum pitches run from 12.5 degrees for its Mendip 12.5 to 25 degrees for the Anglia, with Edgemere and Modern-Duo at 17.5 degrees, Double Roman at 22.5 degrees and Wessex at 15 degrees. Such a spread means a shallow roof narrows the choice to a short list of products, and the pitch has to be measured before any tile is chosen.

Minimum pitches published by Marley for a selection of tiles
TileMaterialMinimum pitch
Lincoln pantileClay15 degrees
AngliaConcrete25 degrees
PlainConcrete35 degrees
Double RomanConcrete22.5 degrees
Mendip 12.5Concrete12.5 degrees

A swap between families is possible when the pitch and the weight allow it, but it changes how the roof reads from the road. That is the point where a conservation area or an Article 4 direction can matter, and it is covered in the last section.

Natural slate, new and reclaimed

Slate is split from rock rather than moulded, so each piece is thin, flat and individual. Cupa, a slate producer, reports 20 degrees as the minimum roof pitch for natural slate under BS 5534, for a 500 mm slate with a 115 mm overlap in a moderate-exposure project. Cupa also advises against hook fixings on any pitch under 25 degrees. Slate therefore asks for a steeper roof than several of the tiles above, and longer slates and bigger overlaps change the answer.

HomeBuilding's lifespan table gives approximate figures: Welsh slate at 100 plus years, Spanish natural slate at 75 to 100 years and reclaimed Welsh slate at 50 to 80 years. Those are published estimates for the material, not promises for your roof, and the battens, nails and underlay beneath a slate have their own lives.

Reclaimed slate is a different purchase from new slate. Each piece has to be sorted, and the supply is limited by what comes off other roofs. Our guide to reclaimed roof tiles covers how a salvaged covering is checked.

Because a slate covering is a different material from a tile one, the weight and fire-performance triggers in the first section both get a look before it is specified. Only the data sheet for each named product gives its weight per square metre, and that figure is what gets compared with the old covering.

Myth

If the pitch is fine, any slate or tile can go on the roof.

Fact

Pitch, weight, fixings and the rules for the address all have to be met for the specific product.

Lifespan and cost, set out with their sources

Lifespan figures come from different publishers, Marley and HomeBuilding, and they do not agree exactly. Marley says that for clay roof tiles "the BRE determined a minimum life expectancy of 60 years", and that "Typically, roof tiles are expected to last for around 60 years", with the line "This is not a guarantee or warranty of its longevity." HomeBuilding's table, last updated 30 September 2025, gives clay tiles 60 to 80 years and plain concrete tiles 40 to 50 years.

Cost figures are third-party averages. For an average three-bedroom house, Which? reports £7,000 to £21,000 excluding VAT for replacing the entire roof, from 11 Trusted Traders surveyed in November 2025. HomeBuilding gives £10,000 to £15,000 as a possible cost for a three-bedroom semi with a 65 m² roof in plain concrete tiles, and says Welsh slate on that house might reach £18,000. On MyJobQuote's page, updated 6 October 2026, the average for fitting a slate roof is around £7,800.

These ranges measure different things, so read them as markers, never as a price for your house. The total shifts with access, the roof's size and shape, and the condition of the structure that the survey reveals. The figure we give is one written total price after the survey.

Published figures for context

Whole roof, average three-bedroom house (Which?)£7,000 to £21,000 excluding VAT, for an average three-bedroom house, entire roof replacement
Plain concrete tiles, 65 m² roof (HomeBuilding)£10,000 to £15,000
Welsh slate, same property (HomeBuilding)might reach £18,000
Fitting a slate roof (MyJobQuote)average around £7,800

Which? Trusted Traders, survey of 11 traders, November 2025, excluding VAT. HomeBuilding, last updated 30 September 2025. MyJobQuote, 6 October 2026, no VAT basis stated.

Planning layers: conservation areas, the Broads and listed homes

Re-roofing a house is normally permitted development under Class C, and a conservation area or the Broads does not remove Class C, which is covered in our planning permission guide. Two layers can still change the choice of covering. An Article 4 direction can withdraw named permitted development rights where it applies, and listed building consent covers any work that alters a listed home's character. Ask the council before you order tiles.

Within the Broads executive area the Broads Authority is the local planning authority, and its phone line for planning is 01603 610734. Building Regulations stay with the district council's building control team or a registered building control approver, whichever side of the boundary the roof sits on. A riverside plot can be inside the line while the road behind is outside it, so check the address rather than the village name.

Our dedicated page on re-roofing in a conservation area goes through like-for-like thinking in detail. A like-for-like covering is the least likely to raise a question, but a covering of the same family can still differ in colour, texture and weight, so the sample is checked against the old one.

The survey looks at each slope, including the ones that did not prompt the call, and anything else spotted is reported in plain words. A photo on WhatsApp can open the conversation. The weight question has its own guide on changing to a heavier roof covering, and the wider job is covered under roof replacement.

Narrowing the choice

  1. Measure the pitch of every slope.
  2. List the products whose minimum pitch fits.
  3. Compare weight per square metre with the old covering.
  4. Ask the council about Article 4, conservation or listing.
  5. Check the fixing specification for the site.
  6. Compare finished samples against the existing roof.

Questions and answers

Can I put a different type of tile on my roof?

Yes, where the pitch, the weight and the address rules all permit it. The pitch has to meet the minimum on the data sheet for that exact product. A covering 15 per cent or more heavier than the old one needs Building Regulations approval. A conservation area, Article 4 direction or listing adds its own checks, so ask the council before ordering.

Is clay or concrete the longer-lasting tile?

Marley and HomeBuilding give different figures. Marley says the BRE determined a minimum life expectancy of 60 years for clay roof tiles. HomeBuilding gives 60 to 80 years for clay and 40 to 50 years for plain concrete. Marley adds a caution that its 60-year figure says nothing certain about any one roof.

Does the covering change what the new roof costs?

It can, along with the size of the roof, access and what the survey finds. Third-party ranges are in the cost table above, each with its source and date. The covering you pick is priced into the single written total that follows the survey. A slate or clay choice and a concrete choice can land far apart, and the third-party ranges in the cost table above give the spread, each with its source and date, so you can see where a figure sits before any quote arrives.

What is the minimum pitch for a slate roof?

Cupa reports 20 degrees under BS 5534 for a 500 mm slate with a 115 mm overlap in a moderate-exposure project, and advises against hook fixings below 25 degrees. A longer slate or a different overlap changes the figure, so the maker's data sheet for the chosen slate decides. Slate therefore suits a steeper roof than several of the tile families above.

Get a written quote

Tell us about your roof

Hand dressing a lead ridge roll with a wooden bossing stick

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing

Call WhatsApp Written quote