Call 01493 277103

Roof replacement

Changing to a Heavier Roof Covering

Swapping one roof covering for another can add load that the rafters, purlins and walls were never sized for. This guide explains the 15 per cent test, who checks the structure, where the weights come from and what else a change of covering triggers.

Get a written quote

Call 01493 277103WhatsApp us

Row of flat-roofed brick lock-up garages with worn felt

Why the weight of a covering is a structural question

Everything on a pitched roof ends up pushing down on something. The covering sits on battens, the battens on rafters, and the rafters pass the load to purlins, wall plates and the walls themselves. A roof was designed, or has settled over the years, for the loads it was built with. When a different covering goes on, the numbers in that chain change, and nobody can see by eye whether the timbers have spare capacity.

Some swaps stay inside the limit and some do not. The rule is written around a threshold, not around a guess: once the new covering is heavier by a stated margin, the work stops being a straightforward re-cover and becomes a matter for Building Regulations. That is why the weight of a covering is looked up and written down before anyone orders a pallet.

Weight is a property of the specific product, not of a material family. Two tiles that look alike can differ in weight per square metre, and two roofs of the same house type can differ in how much they can carry. Throughout this page the comparison is made product against product, using the maker's figure, never by a rule that one material is lighter or heavier than another.

Our guide to choosing a new roof covering sets out the other factors, such as pitch and fixings. This page deals with the weight question alone.

The 15 per cent test, in the two wordings that exist

Two official documents set out the trigger, and they are worded differently. The Planning Portal lists the cases where a re-roof needs Building Regulations approval, and one of them is where you "use a new covering material which increases the weight of the roof covering by 15 per cent or more". Approved Document A, the structural volume of the Building Regulations, says in paragraph 4.4 that "A significant change in roof loading is when the loading upon the roof is increased by more than 15%."

Read the two side by side. The Portal says 15 per cent or more, and Approved Document A says more than 15%. Whichever is quoted, the practical answer is the same: a covering close to that line needs a firm number, and nobody should plan on the basis of an eyeballed difference. Neither wording names a material or a direction of change, so no covering is exempt because of how it is described.

Where the 15 per cent line is written down
SourceWhat it saysWhat it covers
Planning Portal15 per cent or moreWeight of the new roof covering
Approved Document A, para 4.4more than 15%Loading upon the roof

The Portal adds a second trigger that has nothing to do with weight: approval is also needed where "the performance of any new covering will be significantly different" from the existing covering in a fire. That sits beside the weight test rather than inside it, and it is picked up in a later section.

Myth

A covering only needs checking if it is clearly much heavier.

Fact

The test is a percentage, so a modest-looking increase can still reach the line and needs real figures.

What the structural check looks at

The Portal's advice is blunt: where the weight rises, "you are advised to check with a structural engineer or surveyor before commencing with works". That is advice from the Portal, not a requirement spelled out in the quote, but it is the sensible order of events, because the approval, the specification and the price all depend on the answer.

A check starts from the roof as it stands. Rafter size and spacing, the span between supports, the condition of the timber, the state of the purlins and the way the roof bears on the walls are all part of the picture. A roof that has sagged or been altered before gives different readings from one that is still true. Decay and old insect damage reduce what a timber can carry, which is why the structure is looked at as well as the covering.

The loads are then added up. The covering is only one line: battens, underlay, fixings and any added insulation all sit in the total. The engineer or surveyor sets the allowed figure and compares it with the proposal. If the result is tight, the options are a lighter product, a strengthening scheme or a different design.

On a smaller scale, a roof survey from a roofer looks at the same timbers where they can be seen, from the loft or the eaves, and flags anything that looks as though it needs an engineer. We survey the whole roof before quoting, and a worry about the structure is reported in plain words rather than left out of the quote.

What a structural check weighs up

  • Rafter size, spacing and span
  • Purlins and their bearings
  • Timber condition, decay and past alterations
  • How the roof bears on the walls
  • Weight of battens, underlay and fixings
  • The new covering's weight per square metre

Finding and comparing the weights

Manufacturers publish weights on product data sheets, in kilograms per square metre as laid. The words as laid matter, because a figure per tile is a different quantity: how many tiles go to a square metre depends on the gauge and the lap. Sandtoft's clay Old English Pantile is one example. Its data sheet, dated April 2025, gives a weight as laid of 41.6 kg per m², alongside a minimum pitch of 30 degrees and a fixed batten gauge of 290 mm.

To test the 15 per cent line you need two figures: the weight of what is on the roof now and the weight of what is going on. The old one can be harder to pin down, because the product may no longer be made and the data sheet may be gone. A survey can identify the covering and its approximate size, and the new product's data sheet supplies the other side. If the old weight cannot be established, the structural check has to allow for that uncertainty.

The comparison should cover the whole build-up, not the covering alone. A new underlay, thicker battens, counter-battens or added insulation all add to the weight, even when the covering itself is similar. They are kept in the sum so that the final figure is honest.

Be careful with shortcuts. Weights differ product by product, so any claim of that kind should be treated as a prompt to ask for the data sheet. It is the product on the quote, not the family it belongs to, that is compared with the roof as it stands.

Fire performance and the route through building control

A covering that is lighter, or only slightly heavier, can still trigger approval on the Portal's second ground. Where the performance of any new covering will be significantly different from the existing one in the event of a fire, Building Regulations approval is needed. The product's fire classification is on its data sheet, so the comparison can be made on paper.

Building control is carried out by the council's building control team or by a registered building control approver. Registration of private building control approvers with the Building Safety Regulator began on 6 April 2024; only that registration regime is new, since private firms were doing the work before it. Whichever route is used, the covering, the loads and the fire performance are the facts put in front of them. For Great Yarmouth Borough Council addresses and East Suffolk Council addresses, check with that council's building control team.

A complete re-cover goes past the half-way mark on the roof, which takes it outside the Portal's no-application-normally-needed test whatever the covering. The 15 per cent weight question is therefore asked on top of an application that is likely to be needed anyway. Our guide to Building Regulations for re-roofing explains that test in full.

At sign-off, a council's building control team hands over a completion certificate, while a registered approver supplies a final certificate. Either document shows that the new covering went through the approval route.

Planning, appearance and what to do next

Planning is a separate matter from weight. Re-roofing a house is normally permitted development under Class C, so a different covering needs no planning permission on its own account. A conservation area does not remove Class C, but an Article 4 direction can withdraw permitted development rights across a defined area, and listed building consent is needed where work would alter a listed home's character. The Broads Authority is the local planning authority inside its executive area. In every case ask the council before you order.

A change of covering also changes the look of the house, which counts on a terrace, in a street of matching roofs or next to a listed neighbour. Our guide to re-roofing in a conservation area goes through the like-for-like point. Our guide to the roof replacement job as a whole shows where the covering choice sits in the order of work.

In practice the sequence is simple. Decide the covering, find the data sheet, identify what is on the roof now, work out the percentage and let a structural engineer or surveyor confirm the timbers where the figure is anywhere near the line. Then the approval route is settled with building control, and a single written total price follows the survey.

If you are unsure what is on your roof, send a photograph on WhatsApp to 07880 284133 and the roof can be looked at before anything is ordered. A clear picture of the slope, the eaves and any loft timbers you can reach gives the survey a useful starting point.

Before ordering a different covering

  1. Name the covering on the roof now, if it can be identified.
  2. Get the data sheet for the new product.
  3. Compare weight per square metre as laid.
  4. Add underlay, battens and any insulation to both sides.
  5. Ask a structural engineer or surveyor if the gap is near 15%.
  6. Settle the route with building control.

Questions and answers

When does a heavier roof covering need approval?

Per the Planning Portal, Building Regulations approval follows when a new covering material increases the weight of the roof covering by 15 per cent or more. Approved Document A words the threshold as loading upon the roof increased by more than 15%. Name whichever you quote, and ask building control if the figures are close to either line.

Do I need a structural engineer to change my roof covering?

Where the weight rises, the Planning Portal suggests asking a structural engineer or surveyor before work starts. Where the new covering is close to the old one in weight, the maker's data sheets may settle the question on paper. Where it is not, a structural opinion on the rafters and bearings comes first, ahead of the order and the quote.

Can I judge by eye whether a new covering is too heavy?

No. Weight belongs to the specific product, not to a family of material. The weight depends on the specific product, its size and how it is laid, so the comparison is made on the data sheets for the old and new coverings, as laid, per square metre. The same house can pass the test with one product and fail it with another.

Does a different covering need planning permission?

Not on its own account for a house, since no permission is needed for the covering alone. Re-roofing a house is normally permitted development under Class C. A flat changes that answer, a listed home adds listed building consent for work affecting its character, and a conservation area or the Broads does not remove Class C. Ask the council whether an Article 4 direction applies, and ask the Broads Authority inside its area, before you order.

Get a written quote

Tell us about your roof

Hand dressing a lead ridge roll with a wooden bossing stick

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing

Call WhatsApp Written quote