The short answer
Neither word settles it; the resistance class does. Bitumen felt sits in the high-resistance group, a breathable membrane is low resistance, and each asks for different ventilation. Marley's cold-roof figures for high-resistance underlay are 25 mm along the eaves at 15° or less, and 10 mm above 15°.
What the two words describe
Underlay is the flexible layer that goes onto the rafters before the battens and tiles. When people say felt, they mean the traditional bitumen-coated sheet. When they say breathable membrane, they mean a modern plastic sheet designed so that vapour can escape through it. BS 5250 and Marley's guidance sort them by resistance to vapour, in two groups: high resistance (HR) and low resistance (LR).
Bitumen felt is an HR product, so it is not vapour-permeable and holds back vapour from the rooms below. A breathable membrane is LR, so vapour can pass. That difference is why the two cannot simply be exchanged. Damp, warm air drifts up from the rooms to the loft, and what happens to it depends on the sheet it meets.
| Point | Bitumen felt (HR) | Breathable membrane (LR) |
|---|---|---|
| Vapour from the house | Held back by the sheet | Passes through the sheet |
| Cold roof | Eaves ventilation required | Conditions must be met |
| Covering above | Not a factor | Must let air through |
The ventilation each one asks for
A cold roof is one with its insulation at ceiling level, leaving a ventilated space above. Under an HR sheet in a cold roof, Marley's guidance is "25mm along the length of the eaves for pitches of 15° or less; 10mm along the length of the eaves for pitches of more than 15°." BSI lists the code behind this, BS 5250:2021, as current and under review.
- HR sheet, pitch of 15° or under: 25 mm of opening along the eaves.
- HR sheet, steeper than 15°: 10 mm along the eaves.
- LR sheet with every condition met: 3 mm at the eaves, or 5 mm at the ridge.
The LR line comes with conditions, and Marley states them. "Fortuitous ventilation at the eaves via normal eaves construction (3mm) is all that is required", on the condition that the ceiling below is well sealed, the covering is air-permeable and "the requirements of UKAS Third Party certification are fully met". If one is missing, the lighter figure falls away.
Why the tiles above change the answer
Whether air gets through is a property of the covering, which is a separate matter from the sheet beneath it. Calling an underlay breathable says nothing about whether the tile course above it lets air move. A membrane's lighter ventilation line relies on the tiles passing air, so a change of covering during a re-roof can move a roof from one route to the other.
The ceiling counts as well. Warm air from the house that escapes through a loft hatch or recessed lights carries moisture into the space the roof must then deal with. A sheet cannot see how well the ceiling below is sealed, which leaves that to the survey.
Insulation is the other variable. A warm roof, with its insulation at the rafters, sits under different rules from a cold one. CNC Building Control's warm roof easy guide states "No ventilation is required for these types of roofs" for a warm roof and "Ventilation is required for these roofs" for a cold roof. That is CNC's own wording, and the build-up of the roof decides which applies. A roof converted or insulated after it was built may have changed from one type to the other, which is another reason to look before choosing a sheet.
What to ask before you agree an underlay
Once the loft has been looked at, a roofer should be able to answer four questions plainly. Put the answers in writing before you sign, so the underlay is a named product on the quote rather than a line that says membrane.
- Which underlay is proposed, and is it HR or LR?
- Is the roof cold or warm, and how is the space ventilated?
- Does the new covering let air through?
- Which product certificate or data sheet backs the answer?
At Total Roofing Great Yarmouth the survey looks into the loft as well as across the slopes, and you get one written total price with the findings in plain words. The data sheet for the underlay, not a sales label, is what states its class. Ask to see it, and ask the same of any other firm quoting for the job, since two quotes that both say breathable can describe different products with different needs.
Our insulating when re-roofing guide covers the warm and cold roof choice, and the re-roofing process guide shows where the underlay goes in. Both belong to roof replacement.


