The short answer
Yes, in principle, but check four things first. A covering 15 per cent or more heavier needs Building Regulations approval, so the structure comes first. Then the look, whether an Article 4 direction, conservation area or listing applies, and whether the roof pitch suits the new tile.
The weight check
A roof's rafters were sized for the covering that was on it. Swapping to a different tile changes the load they carry, and the rules treat a big change as a structural question. The Planning Portal says that if you use a new covering material which increases the weight of the roof covering by "15 per cent or more", Building Regulations approval is needed, and it advises checking with a structural engineer or surveyor before starting. Approved Document A frames the same line as a loading "increased by more than 15%".
The two wordings are not identical, so we name the one we rely on. The test is about the change in weight, so the label on the material does not settle it: what counts is the weight of each covering as laid, compared on the roof in question. The weight of the new tile comes from its own product data sheet, set against the old covering.
Our answer on how heavy clay pantiles are gives one maker's weight for a clay pantile, which is the starting figure for any comparison. A full re-roof also touches over half the roof, which puts it beyond the no-application test whatever goes on.
Pitch and the product
Both clay and concrete pantiles exist, so a swap need not change the shape. The difference is the product. Each tile comes with its maker's minimum pitch, headlap and batten gauge. Sandtoft's data sheet gives its clay Old English Pantile a minimum pitch of 30 degrees, a 75 mm headlap and a batten gauge fixed at 290 mm. From Marley's list: 15 degrees for the Lincoln clay pantile, 25 degrees for the concrete Anglia.
A concrete tile made for a steeper slope than the roof's will let the weather in, so the pitch of the existing roof is measured before a replacement is chosen. A flatter roof than a tile's minimum is a reason to choose another product, not a reason to bend the rule.
The side-by-side picture of the two materials is in our guide to clay and concrete pantiles, and the concrete interlocking tiles that are not pantile-shaped are covered in concrete interlocking roof tiles.
Tile terms in this answer
- HeadlapHow far one course of tiles overlaps the next
- Batten gaugeThe spacing between the timber battens the tiles hang on
- Minimum pitchThe shallowest roof angle the tile is made for
- UnderlayThe membrane under the tiles that catches stray water
Planning, listing and the Broads
Re-roofing a house is normally permitted development under Class C, and that does not change because the new tile is a different type. What can change it is the address. An Article 4 direction can remove further permitted development rights, so we check with the council first. A listed home keeps those rights, but a listed house needs consent for work that touches its special character.
Conservation areas add a local view of how a roof should look. Whether a particular direction names roof coverings depends on the council's notice, so the safe step is to ask the council whether an Article 4 direction applies to the address before choosing a tile. In the Broads, the Broads Authority decides planning for the land inside its executive area, and the district council decides elsewhere, so the address settles who to ask.
Class C is untouched by the Broads, which removes roof enlargements such as dormers from permitted development rather than re-roofing. Replacing pantiles with another tile is a re-roof, but the look of a different tile on a street of clay roofs is the part that conservation officers care about, so the question goes to the council early.
How it looks, and what it costs
A concrete pantile does not weather the way clay does. The surface colour and texture differ, and a new concrete roof can read as flatter than the clay it replaces, especially next to neighbouring roofs of the old material. This is a matter of taste and of local character, and the survey is the point to talk it through, with the tile samples laid beside the old ones in daylight.
On cost, HomeBuilding (last updated 30 September 2025) says a three-bedroom semi, standard, with a 65m2 roof and plain concrete tiles, may cost between £10,000 and £15,000. For an average three-bedroom house, Which? Trusted Traders give a figure for the entire roof replaced: £7,000 to £21,000, excluding VAT (November 2025). Neither is a pantile price, and the tile is just one of the things that move a total.
Your total comes after the survey, once the slope, the timbers and the consent route have all been looked at. Our pitched roofing page lists the other tiled roof work we do.


