One shape, two materials
A clay pantile is moulded from clay and fired in a kiln. A concrete pantile is cast from cement and sand, then cured and coloured. The finished tiles can look close to each other from the ground, which is why people sometimes assume they behave alike. They do not: each makes its own claims for pitch, weight and life, and the figures sit on that product's data sheet.
That is the first rule of any comparison. A tile is compared by its product, not by its material. A concrete tile from one maker is not the same as a concrete tile from another, and a clay pantile from one kiln differs from the next. When a person says clay lasts longer or concrete is cheaper, check which tile they mean and which sheet they have read.
Names add confusion. Canterbury and Anglia are Marley products, not places and not kinds of roof, and the Lincoln is a clay pantile where the Anglia is a concrete one. Our guide to what a pantile roof is explains the shape and the words that go with it, and the pitched roofing hub covers the rest. The comparison that follows uses the makers' own published numbers wherever they exist, and says so where they do not.
How the two are made
Clay pantile
- Moulded clay
- Fired in a kiln
- Fired colour
Concrete pantile
- Cement and sand
- Cast and cured
- Colour added
Minimum pitch
Pitch means how steeply the roof slopes, measured in degrees, and each tile has a minimum below which water can be driven back under the laps. Marley lists 15 degrees for the Lincoln, its clay pantile, and 25 degrees for the concrete Anglia. Sandtoft's data sheet gives its clay Old English Pantile a minimum pitch of 30 degrees, with a 75 mm headlap.
| Tile | Material | Minimum pitch |
|---|---|---|
| Marley Lincoln pantile | Clay | 15 degrees |
| Sandtoft Old English Pantile | Clay | 30 degrees |
| Marley Anglia | Concrete | 25 degrees |
The table shows the clay pantiles with the lowest and highest minimum, and that the material alone does not decide the figure. A clay tile can sit below a concrete one, as the Lincoln does, and above it, as the Old English does. Measuring the roof's slope comes first and the tile choice second. A pitch measured in degrees from the rafter line, and not guessed from the street, is what the sheet is checked against. Our guide to re-roofing in clay pantiles covers the batten gauge and headlap that go with the pitch.
Marley's wider list shows how far the figures spread. Among its clay tiles it gives 40 degrees for Canterbury, 35 for Ashdowne, 30 for Hawkins and for Acme Single Camber, and 15 for Lincoln. Among its concrete tiles the range runs from 12.5 degrees for Mendip 12.5 up to 35 for its plain tile. Only some of those are pantiles, but the spread shows why the roof's slope is checked against one product's sheet and not against a rule about the material.
Weight and the structural check
Weight is where changing material can have consequences. The Planning Portal lists approval as needed where you "use a new covering material which increases the weight of the roof covering by 15 per cent or more", and it says "you are advised to check with a structural engineer or surveyor before commencing with works". Approved Document A puts the line a little differently, treating a loading "increased by more than 15%" as a significant change, so the two sources are named separately.
The comparison is made from data sheets. On Sandtoft's sheet, the clay Old English Pantile comes to 41.6 kg per m² laid. Each product states its own figure, and the weight of the new covering is set against the old one, not against a general rule about clay and concrete. A direction of change, such as one material being heavier than another, cannot be assumed without the two sheets in hand.
If the new covering is 15 per cent or more heavier, the roof structure is checked and building control approval is needed. That applies in any change of covering, whether the new tile is clay, concrete or something else. A structural engineer or surveyor decides what the rafters and the walls can carry, and the written quote is prepared after that is known. Our own survey looks at the roof and tells you what it found, but the structural calculation is the engineer's.
Checking a change of covering
- Find the weight of the old covering.
- Read the weight of the new one on its sheet.
- Compare the two per square metre.
- If it is 15 per cent or more heavier, ask an engineer.
- Ask building control about approval.
- Choose the tile once the answer is in.
How long each is published to last
Lifespans are estimates, not promises, and the published figures differ. For clay, Marley writes: "For clay roof tiles, the BRE determined a minimum life expectancy of 60 years". HomeBuilding's table gives clay tiles 60-80 years. The BRE figure applies to clay alone.
For concrete, HomeBuilding gives plain concrete tiles 40-50 years, and Marley writes: "Typically, roof tiles are expected to last for around 60 years", followed by "This is not a guarantee or warranty of its longevity." Both sources are named because their figures differ. HomeBuilding's figure is for plain concrete tiles, not for concrete pantiles specifically.
- Clay tiles: HomeBuilding's range of 60-80 years
- Plain concrete tiles: HomeBuilding's range of 40-50 years
- Roof tiles generally: Marley's around 60 years, with its own caution
What a particular roof achieves depends on its fixings, its battens and underlay and how it has been looked after, so a table of years is a guide to the material, not a forecast for your roof. Two houses with the same tile can have different outcomes when one has sound battens and the other has rotted ones. A survey of the roof as it stands tells you more about the years left than any published figure.
How they look, and why it matters on an old roof
Clay is fired, and its colour comes from the clay and the firing, so it varies from tile to tile and weathers in its own way. Concrete takes its colour from pigment or a surface coat, and it ages differently. On a new roof, either can be chosen for its colour. On a re-roof, the choice is judged against the old tiles beside it and against the street.
Where the house is listed, the appearance of the roof is part of its character, and listed building consent covers works carried out "in any manner which would affect its character as a building of special architectural or historic interest". Replacing clay with concrete is the kind of change that the council will want to see before it is done, and the Broads Authority will too inside its executive area. In a conservation area, check with the council whether an Article 4 direction applies before a different tile is ordered.
Inside the Broads executive area, planning is decided by the Broads Authority, and the district council's building control team or a registered approver handles Building Regulations. For a house, a change of covering normally falls under Class C, even in a conservation area; a listed house also needs listed building consent where the work would affect its character, an Article 4 direction can remove the right, and the weight and fixing checks still apply.
What the cost guides say, and what they do not
Published cost guides price a whole roof by house size and covering, and none of the ones we draw on separates clay pantiles from concrete pantiles. Which? Trusted Traders put replacing the whole roof of an average three-bedroom house at £7,000 to £21,000, excluding VAT, in a survey of 11 traders in November 2025. MyJobQuote gives around £5,250 as the average new roof in the UK, on its page dated 3 November 2026.
For a three-bedroom semi that has a 65m² roof in plain concrete tiles, HomeBuilding's page, last updated 30 September 2025, gives between £10,000 and £15,000, and it adds that the cost of Welsh slate for that property might reach £18,000. Those are plain concrete tiles, not concrete pantiles, so treat them as a sense of scale and not as a clay-versus-concrete comparison. They also depend on what the roof needs besides the tiles.
A price for your own roof comes after a survey, because the cost depends on its size, the access, the state of the timbers and the tile. Our guide to what pitched roof repairs cost gives published repair figures with their sources and dates. After our survey the written quote gives one total price for the work described.
Choosing between them for your roof
Start with the roof you have, and write the figures down: the pitch, the batten spacing you can see from the loft and the rough area of each slope. Measure the pitch, read the data sheet of any tile you are considering and compare its weight with the old covering. Then check the planning and consent route for the address with the council, or with the Broads Authority inside its executive area. Only after those answers are in does colour or price settle the choice. A tile that fails on pitch or weight is not rescued by looking right, and a tile that passes both can still be ruled out by a conservation area.
If you are replacing like with like, a match in profile, headlap and gauge keeps the battens as they are. A change of material can mean new battens and perhaps work to the roof structure, as the gauge and the weight are different, which is why the structural check comes first and the order for tiles comes last.
The survey covers the whole roof, not only the area being re-covered, and the findings are written up plainly, together with anything else that was seen. If you would like a first look, send a photo of the roof on WhatsApp. We arrange the licence with our scaffolder where scaffold is needed over the pavement or road.
Whatever the tile, the fixings follow the current standard. BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 is current, Marley says installing to it isn't required by law, and since the 2015 amendments, mortar cannot be relied upon as the only means of securing the roof covering, so fixings are specified for clay and concrete alike.


