Call 01493 277103

Pitched roofing

Gable or Hip Roof: What's the Difference?

A gable roof ends in a wall that rises to the ridge, and a hip roof ends in a slope. The difference decides which tiles sit at the edge, what fixes them and what a survey checks.

Get a written quote

Call 01493 277103WhatsApp us

Roofer behind a brick chimney with fresh flaunching around two pots Roofer on a scaffold tower working on a brick chimney stack

The short answer

A gable roof ends in a triangle of wall at each end, with the roof edge finished as a verge. A hip roof slopes at the ends too, with tiles running along each sloping corner. Both need their edge tiles held by a mechanical fixing, and neither shape is exempt from upkeep.

The difference at the ends

Both roofs have the same long slopes and the same ridge along the top. They differ in what happens at each end of the building.

On a gable roof the end wall carries up to the ridge in a triangle, and the roof stops against it. The sloping edge where the tiles meet that wall is the verge. On a hip roof there is no triangle of wall. A third plane of tiles slopes down at the end, and the sloping lines where it meets the long slopes are the hips.

The two shapes therefore pose different questions. A gable asks how the verge is finished and fixed, and a hip asks the same about the hip line, where cut tiles must follow a diagonal. A house can mix them. A half-hip slopes only the upper part of the end, and some homes have a hipped front and a gable at the back.

The page on what a hip roof is explains the hip in more detail.

Gable and hip compared

Gable and hip roofs side by side
FeatureGableHip
The end of the roofA wall rising to the ridgeA slope of tiles
The edge detailA verge along each endHip tiles along each corner
The cut tilesTiles trimmed to the wall lineTiles trimmed to a diagonal
The loft at the endsFull height to the wallSpace narrows under the slope
Fixing at the edgeVerge tiles fixed mechanicallyHip tiles fixed mechanically

The loft row is general: the shape of the roof decides how much headroom a loft has near the walls, and a hipped end gives less than a gable. A conversion on either shape needs its own checks with building control. Re-covering the whole roof is outside the small-works test that the Planning Portal gives for re-roofing, because the Portal limits that test to work on less than 50 per cent of the roof, whether the roof is a gable or a hip. Building control at your council can confirm the route.

Edges, fixings and the wind

Both shapes put tiles along an edge that has open air beside it, and BS 5534 treats the edge as a place for firm fixing. Marley advises a mechanical fixing for every ridge or hip tile, sized to the wind uplift worked out for the roof, and adds that mortar by itself no longer secures the covering since the 2015 amendments. On a gable, the same thinking applies to the verge, which is why dry verge systems exist and why BS 8612:2018 covers verges as well as ridges and hips.

Wind alone does not settle the choice. What separates a roof's performance is the fixing specification written for its site, which takes in how exposed the roof is, along with how well the tiles at each edge were fixed and how they have aged.

That is worth knowing if you are comparing the two for a new build or an extension. Choose the shape for the plan and the planning route, not on a belief that one resists weather better. Our page on what a dry verge is shows what a modern gable edge can look like.

Upkeep: what each shape asks of a roof

Each shape has its own checks. On a gable, the verge is looked at for cracked or missing mortar, a loose end tile, a bargeboard that is rotting beneath the edge, and any dry verge unit that has lifted. On a hip, the checks are the hip tiles along each diagonal, the bedding, the cut tiles beside them, the hip iron at the foot and the point where the hips meet the ridge.

A hip roof has more hip lines to maintain but no verges, and a gable has verges but no hips. The counts of edges differ without the jobs differing much in kind. What decides the cost is length, access and the condition found, not the name of the shape.

At Total Roofing Great Yarmouth the survey takes in every edge, the ridge and the covering together, and tells you what it found. We price hip work after the survey, since ridge prices do not apply to hips, and our quote is one written total price. For the whole range of jobs, see the pitched roofing service.

Questions and answers

Which is better, a gable roof or a hip roof?

Neither is better in itself. A gable gives a full-height loft at the ends and a simple verge detail, while a hip gives a roof that slopes on every side and a line of hip tiles to maintain. The choice rests on the plan, the planning route and the look of the street, and each shape can be fixed well or badly.

Can a gable roof be changed to a hip roof?

It can be built, but it alters the shape of the roof, so the work needs checking with building control and the planning route at your address, listed status and conservation areas included. It also changes the loft, because the new slope takes space from it. A structural survey comes before any drawing.

Do gable ends need more maintenance than hips?

The tasks differ rather than the amount. A gable has verges to keep sound and a hip has hip lines, each with tiles cut to fit and a fixing that can fail. Looking at both from the ground, with binoculars if needed, shows a loose tile, and a survey on the roof confirms what is behind it.

Get a written quote

Tell us about your roof

Hand dressing a lead ridge roll with a wooden bossing stick

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing

Call WhatsApp Written quote