The short answer
A lead roof leaks where the lead has split, where a joint has opened, where damp or fresh mortar has attacked the underside, where a fixing has failed, or where water stands against a weak point. A survey establishes which, because the stain indoors can sit well away from the fault.
Splits and open joints
Lead roofs are laid in sheets, joined along rolls, which run with the fall, and drips, which are small steps across it. Both are made to let each sheet move as the temperature changes. Where a sheet has been cut too long, or the movement has been blocked, it splits, and the split can sit at a roll, a drip, a fold or a corner.
An open joint is the other main fault. A lap that has pulled apart, a roll whose cover has lifted or a seam that was never fused leaves a path for water. These faults sit close to the surface and show in a close-range photograph, though roof work at height is for a competent person.
Our answer on why lead flashing cracks explains the mechanism of a split. A flat lead roof is covered in the guide to lead flat roofs, which shows how the sheets are laid and where each joint sits, and a lead roof can leak at any of them.
Damage you cannot see from above
Lead can fail from underneath. The metal does not rust, but its underside can be attacked where it lies on damp timber, or against fresh lime or cement mortar, and it can be eaten through in patches that look sound from above. A survey checks for it by looking at the underside of the sheet where it can be reached.
- Pinholes or a pitted, powdery white deposit on the lead's underside.
- Lead that looks sound above but is thin, brittle or crumbling when handled.
- Damp or rotten boards beneath the sheet, where water has been trapped.
- Condensation inside a flat roof, which wets the underside without any hole above.
That last point matters for diagnosis. Damp indoors under a lead roof is not always a hole in the lead, because condensation on the underside can produce the same stain. A leak that appears in cold, still weather, with no rain, points that way. The cause of a stain is something the survey has to establish, not something that can be assumed from the ceiling. Roofs with a lead covering over boards on a flat deck are the cases where this is worth ruling out early.
Fixings, outlets and standing water
Lead is held down with clips and fixings, and when those fail the sheet lifts or slides. A nail driven through the open face of a sheet leaves a hole that water can use, and a clip that has corroded or pulled out lets a lower edge lift in the wind and take rain under it.
Water that cannot get away is the third group. A blocked outlet, a full rainwater pipe or a sheet laid with a dip in it leaves water standing on the lead. Standing water presses on every weak point and keeps a seam wet long enough to test it. Clearing an outlet is a quick check that costs nothing, and it can show whether ponding is the cause. A blocked outlet can also raise the water level until it reaches a joint that sits clear of it when the roof drains freely.
Where lead meets a wall, the flashing is another candidate, since a gap at the top edge lets water down behind the lead. Our page on the signs your lead flashing has failed lists what to look for at a wall junction, and the guide on lead valley replacement covers the gutter between two slopes.
Finding the cause and what comes next
Rain can travel along a board or a rafter before it drips, so the ceiling stain does not mark the hole. A diagnosis comes from looking at the roof itself: the sheets, the joints, the fixings, the outlets and the upstands, and then the structure beneath.
Keep off the roof. Photograph the stain indoors, check that the outlets are clear if you can see them from a window, and WhatsApp a photo to us or request a survey. If the leak followed a storm, record the damage in photos before it is disturbed: the Financial Ombudsman Service says "we'll usually look at expert reports and photos".
The survey looks over the entire roof rather than just the spot you rang about, and you receive one total price. The lead roofing and leadwork hub lists the lead jobs, and a page on lead flashing cost gives dated third-party figures for the smaller jobs.


