Box gutters and valley gutters on a unit
A domestic gutter hangs from the eaves and sheds water onto the ground. Industrial and commercial buildings use a different arrangement. A valley gutter runs along the line where two roof slopes meet, collecting water from both. A box gutter is a rectangular channel formed inside the roof, along a parapet or between a wall and the roof edge. Each is built into the building and not hung from it, so each is far more work to renew than a clip-on gutter.
They are made from several materials. Older buildings may have a gutter formed from lead, galvanised steel or asbestos cement, laid on timber or steel supports. Newer units have gutters formed from the same coated steel as the roof, or from a membrane laid over boards. The material matters because it governs what can be done with a leaking gutter, and the survey identifies it before anything is priced.
A single gutter can serve a very large roof area. On a unit with a wide span, one valley collects water from two long slopes and delivers it to a few outlets at the end. A fault in that one channel puts the whole roof's water into the building at one point, which is why a gutter leak is treated as a priority and not left for the next maintenance round.
Our warehouse roof repairs guide covers the other leak points on a sheeted roof. This page concentrates on the gutter itself and on the decision between lining it and replacing it.
Why a commercial gutter fails
Blocked outlets are the simplest cause. Leaves, litter, bird nests and moss wash into the gutter and gather over the outlet. Water rises behind the blockage, stands in the channel and then finds the seams of the lining, the laps of the sheets above or the top of the upstand. A gutter that stands full of water works every joint harder than one that drains, and the extra weight of that water loads the supports beneath it.
Ponding causes the long-term damage. If the gutter was laid with too little fall, or if it has sagged between its supports, water stays in the low spots after rain. Brett Martin gives the fall for guttering as downward towards the outlet, "1mm for every 600mm", and NFRC reports that BS 6229:2025 sets "a minimum 1:80 finished fall for general roof areas and internal gutters". A gutter that does not meet those figures holds water at the places where the lining is most stressed.
Material faults follow. Steel gutters rust from the base upwards where water lies against them. Joints in sheet metal open as the metal expands and contracts. Bitumen and felt linings crack and blister as they age. Seams in a membrane lift where the adhesive has given up. In each case a small hole in a hidden channel lets water through for a long time before a stain shows inside.
The cause decides the repair. A lining laid over a gutter with a blocked outlet will fail for the same reason as the old one, and a lining laid over a sagging channel keeps the pond it was meant to cure. The survey finds the cause first, and it follows the gutter along its whole length, because a fault in one section can be a symptom of movement in the structure under another.
Causes found when a gutter is surveyed
- Blocked or undersized outlets
- Standing water from sag or too little fall
- Rust through the gutter floor or sides
- Open joints between metal sections
- Cracked or lifted lining and seams
- Missing overflows at the end of the run
Lining against replacement
Lining means coating or covering the inside of the existing gutter with a new waterproof layer, bonded to the metal or board that is already there, so the old channel becomes the support for a new surface. Replacement means taking out the old gutter and putting in a new one. Both end with a watertight channel, and a reader weighing them up should see where they differ: they differ in disruption, access, what each can cure and what each leaves behind.
| Point | Lining | Replacement |
|---|---|---|
| What it does | Coats or covers the existing channel | Removes it and fits a new gutter |
| Sheets above | Stay in place | Lifted or cut back at the edge |
| Cures a sag | No, unless the supports are fixed first | Yes, the new gutter is laid to a fall |
| Works on rusted steel | If the metal is sound after preparation | Yes, the rusted metal goes |
| Disturbance | Less structural disturbance | More strip-out and making good |
Lining suits a gutter whose channel is sound but whose waterproofing has failed, with enough fall, solid supports and metal or boards that will hold a coating after preparation. It leaves the roof sheets alone, which matters on a building that cannot be opened up, such as a unit with racking and stock directly under the gutter line. A lined gutter keeps the existing outlets and the existing sheet edges, so the roof above stays as it was while only the channel changes. Replacement suits a gutter that is rusted through, bowed, out of fall or built from a material that cannot carry a lining. It also suits a gutter that has already been lined once and has failed again, because a second coating over a first does not remove whatever caused the failure.
The decision is made on what the survey finds, and price follows it. A commercial gutter is priced after the survey, because the length, the access and the state of the channel set the figure, with a single written total at the end.
How a lining goes on
Preparation is most of the job. The gutter is cleared of debris and silt, and loose rust, flaking paint and old lining are removed back to a sound edge. Holes and splits are repaired, joints are sealed and the surface is cleaned and left dry, because a coating applied over damp metal or board does not bond. Dryness is the reason gutter lining is a dry-weather job, and a spell of rain can stop work half way along a run.
A primer goes on next, matched to the surface, steel, board or old membrane. The lining then goes on in layers. Depending on the system it can be a liquid-applied coating, a glass-fibre reinforced layer, a sheet membrane bonded or welded into the channel or a combination of these. Corners, joints and outlets get extra reinforcement, because they are where movement and water concentrate.
Details finish the work. The lining is turned up the sides of the gutter and under the edge of the sheets above, and it is dressed into each outlet so water cannot run behind it. An overflow, a safety opening set below the top of the channel, lets water leave if an outlet blocks, so that it runs out of the building and not into it. The survey checks that the overflow exists and sits at the right height, and that its pipe or opening is clear and visible from outside, so that an overflowing gutter shows itself before the water reaches the stock.
Order of work for a lined gutter
- Clear debris and check the outlets run freely.
- Cut out rust and repair holes, splits and joints.
- Dry the channel and prime the prepared surface.
- Apply the lining in layers, reinforcing joints and corners.
- Dress the lining into each outlet and up the sides.
- Check the fall and overflow, then test with water.
What a lining cannot fix
A lining is a waterproof skin, not a structure. It cannot straighten a sagging gutter, replace a rotted timber support or add the fall that was never built in. If the survey shows that the channel is bowed or the support has failed, the support is repaired before any coating goes on, or the gutter is replaced.
It cannot be applied to a damp substrate, and it cannot hold on a surface that is still rusting from beneath. Where steel has rusted through, a patch or a new section has to go in first. A coating over live rust blisters and lifts, and the gutter leaks again at the same place.
Asbestos needs a separate decision. HSE's non-licensed list names asbestos cement products, including "roof sheeting and rainwater goods", so an old asbestos cement gutter counts as asbestos. HSE says: "If the building was built or refurbished before 2000, assume that there is asbestos in it." A broken-up asbestos cement gutter is notifiable non-licensed work, and waste goes into a lockable skip, never an open one. Norfolk County Council does not accept any asbestos at its recycling centres, so disposal goes through a specialist route. Our commercial roof maintenance guide explains how checking and clearing gutters fits into the care of a roof.
Reaching the gutter and working around the unit
Box and valley gutters are inside the roof, so reaching them means getting onto it. The roof around a gutter can be fragile, and the gutter is a point where sheets end against a wall or a purlin and the surface is hardest to judge. Edge protection and a safe way up come before the first tool, and any mobile platform or scaffold is placed clear of the loading doors. Scaffolding on the pavement or road needs a highway licence from the county council; we arrange the licence with our scaffolder.
The unit carries on trading underneath. Lining a gutter needs dry weather and a clear channel, but not an empty building. The occupier says which bays have stock that has to stay dry and which doors stay in use, and the work is laid out in lengths so only a section of gutter is open at a time. Between sections the open end of the channel is closed off, so a shower in the afternoon does not put water into a bay that was dry in the morning.
After the survey we say what the gutter needs and give one written total. Send a picture of the gutter or the ceiling mark to 07880 284133 on WhatsApp and we will look at it before a visit is booked. If the gutter ties into a flat roof, see our flat roofing systems guide for how the covering and the gutter work together.


