The short answer
Yes, a listed chimney can be repaired, but work that affects the building's character needs listed building consent, and the council decides what counts. Churches in use follow their own system, the faculty route for the Church of England. Check with the council before any stack work starts.
What the consent test says
The law on listed buildings is the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990. Its section 7 requires listed building consent for work to a listed building "in any manner which would affect its character as a building of special architectural or historic interest". The test turns on the effect of the work, not on how big the job is. A chimney stack is part of what gives a listed house its outline, so renewing pointing, rebuilding the top courses or changing the pots can all fall under it.
Listed homes keep their permitted development rights for roof work, but listed building consent is needed for anything that affects the building's character. Those are two separate permissions. The rule that lets a house be re-roofed without a planning application is also limited where chimneys are concerned: it excludes the installation, alteration or replacement of a chimney. So a repair that goes beyond patching deserves a question to the council before anyone orders materials.
The council makes the call, not the roofer and not you. The way to find out whether your repair needs consent is to ask the council's planning team, with a description or a photograph of the work in mind. A repair that is judged not to affect character may go ahead without consent, but that decision belongs to the council.
Churches, chapels and ministers' houses
Churches in use are treated differently. The ecclesiastical exemption in the 1990 Act lifts listed building consent from a church used for ecclesiastical purposes. A 2010 order keeps it for Church of England churches within the faculty jurisdiction and for the Roman Catholic, Methodist and United Reformed churches, each under its own system. In Great Yarmouth, the Minster Church of St Nicholas is a Church of England parish church, so repairs there go through the faculty system. The Diocese of Norwich calls it "the largest parish church in the country".
The exemption is narrower than it sounds. It stands in for listed building consent and nothing else, so planning permission still has to be settled for the exterior. Several buildings sit outside it:
- Unitarian and Quaker meeting houses, which are not exempt and need listed building consent.
- Redundant churches and those vested in the Churches Conservation Trust.
- A minister's house, which the Act excludes from the exemption.
- A scheduled monument, where Historic England receives the applications and the decision sits with the Secretary of State.
The survey on an old, listed stack
The survey on a listed home looks at the stack the way it looks at any other, from the roof: pointing, brick faces, the flaunching under the pot, the flashings and the tiles around the base. It then reports plainly what it found. What differs is what happens next, because the answer to "repair or rebuild" is a question for consent as well as for the brickwork, and the council may want to see the proposal before the work is priced as final.
Materials matter more on an old stack. Repointing that uses a mortar unsuited to the brick, or a replacement brick that does not match, changes how the stack looks and behaves, which is the kind of change the character test is about. For the work itself, our guides on chimney repointing and chimney stack rebuild cover what each involves.
Where lead is part of the repair, MyJobQuote says correctly installed lead flashing can last for over 80 years, and a sound flashing in good condition is worth keeping and dressing back rather than replacing for its own sake.
Before the work starts
We check the planning or listed building route with the council before work starts. The price we write after the survey is a single total. Where consent is needed, the work waits for it. A stack shared with a neighbour adds a separate step: cutting a flashing into a party wall is party structure work under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996, with notice due at least two months before the date on which the proposed work will begin.
Which council you ask depends on the address, and inside the Broads executive area the Broads Authority is the local planning authority. Check the address with the council's planning team. You can also send a photograph to WhatsApp 07880 284133, and the survey will cover the whole roof, not only the chimney that prompted the call.
The main page on chimney repairs lists the other stack and flue problems we cover.


