Two families of covering, not two products
Natural slate is split stone, cut into thin flat rectangles that overlap down the slope. Tiles are fired clay or cast concrete, and they come in several shapes: flat plain tiles, interlocking tiles and curved pantiles. A question about slate against tile is really about three or four coverings, and the answer shifts with the one you pick.
That shift is why published figures need care. A price for concrete interlocking tiles says little about a clay pantile roof, and a lifespan given for plain concrete tiles does not carry across to clay. Every figure below comes with its source, its date and the house or product it describes, so you can judge which ones fit your own situation.
Nothing here assumes a particular covering is native to Great Yarmouth, the Broads or the villages around them. The facts that follow hold on any roof in the area, and the choice itself gets made on the slope of the roof rather than in a showroom.
Pitch, weight, price and lifespan each pull in a different direction, which is why a single verdict from a leaflet does not match a real house. Seeing how each factor behaves on its own makes it easier to weigh them together once the survey has put numbers on your roof.
Terms used in this post
- PitchThe roof slope, measured in degrees
- HeadlapHow far each course covers the next one down
- BattenThe timber strip each course is fixed to
- PantileA curved interlocking tile, in clay or concrete
- UnderlayThe membrane laid beneath the battens
Slate against tile: where the money figures sit
Start with the widest range. A Which? Trusted Traders survey of 11 traders in November 2025 priced a complete re-cover of an average three-bedroom house at £7,000 to £21,000, excluding VAT. That spread spans every covering, so it cannot settle slate against tile by itself.
One source names both coverings for a single house. HomeBuilding, last updated 30 September 2025, imagines a standard three-bedroom semi with a 65 m² roof: the estimate for plain concrete tiles runs from £10,000 to £15,000, while the Welsh slate version might reach £18,000. HomeBuilding gives both as estimates, so read them as an indication rather than a quote.
MyJobQuote publishes averages page by page. Its slate page (6 October 2026) calls around £7,800 the average cost of a slate roof, while its new roof page (3 November 2026) calls around £5,250 the average for a new roof. Neither names a house size, so setting one against the other proves nothing. Each is one data point.
Repairs sit on another basis again. Checkatrade's June 2026 table, exclusive of VAT, gives £110 to £160 per m² for repairing a pitched clay tile roof and around £190 per m² for natural slate. Those rates apply to the patch being mended, never to a whole roof. Our own quotes are one total price in writing, settled once the survey of the roof is finished, and the slate roof cost guide goes deeper into the figures.
Published figures, each with its source
| Complete roof (Which?) | £7,000 to £21,000 for an average three-bedroom house, excluding VAT |
|---|---|
| Plain concrete tiles, 65 m² semi (HomeBuilding) | may cost £10,000 to £15,000 |
| Welsh slate, same semi (HomeBuilding) | might reach £18,000 |
| Slate roof, average (MyJobQuote) | average of around £7,800 |
| Repairs per m², clay then slate (Checkatrade) | £110 to £160, then around £190 |
Which?: 11 Trusted Traders, November 2025, excluding VAT. HomeBuilding: last updated 30 September 2025. MyJobQuote: slate page 6 October 2026, no VAT basis stated. Checkatrade: June 2026 table, exclusive of VAT, per m² of repair.
Pitch decides which coverings can go on the slope
Minimum pitch is set product by product, and a roof cannot take anything that needs a steeper slope than the one it has. The figures come from the makers and differ product to product, so a blanket claim that tiles need less slope than slate, or the reverse, would be wrong. The sheet for each tile governs that tile.
For natural slate, Cupa reports that BS 5534 sets a floor of 20 degrees where exposure is moderate, with a 500 mm slate lapped 115 mm. Cupa adds that hooks have no place on a pitch under 25 degrees. For tiles, For the clay Old English Pantile, Sandtoft's data sheet gives a 30 degree floor and a 75 mm headlap. In Marley's list, the Lincoln clay pantile appears at 15 degrees and the concrete Anglia at 25 degrees.
Two practical points follow. A roof fixed for one product cannot swap to another on looks alone, because the slope has to suit the new one. And Lincoln and Anglia are Marley product names, not places or tile types, so the same word on two quotes need not mean the same tile.
Fixings are a separate decision from the covering. A fixing specification under BS 5534 is worked out for the individual site and allows for exposure, so one slate or tile can be secured two ways on two roofs.
Published minimum pitches
- Natural slate (Cupa, BS 5534, moderate exposure): 20 degrees
- Slate hook fixings (Cupa): not below 25 degrees
- Sandtoft clay Old English Pantile: 30 degrees
- Marley clay Lincoln pantile: 15 degrees
- Marley concrete Anglia: 25 degrees
Rafters, weight and the approval threshold
Plenty of owners assume one covering is the heavy option and the other the light one. This post ranks neither, because published guidance does not rank slate and tile as classes. They do publish a threshold. The Planning Portal puts the line at 15 per cent or more: a replacement material that adds that much weight to the covering needs Building Regulations approval. Approved Document A names a loading increase of more than 15% as a significant change.
The Portal also advises speaking to a structural engineer or surveyor before work starts, whichever covering you are heading towards. Approval can be required as well when the new covering would behave significantly differently in a fire.
One product's weight gives scale and nothing more: Sandtoft's clay Old English Pantile weighs 41.6 kg per m² as laid, according to its data sheet. That figure belongs to one tile and says nothing about slate or about other tiles.
A second Building Regulations question has no link to weight. The Planning Portal says an application is normally not needed when less than 25 per cent of the building envelope is affected and less than 50 per cent of the roof is affected. Stripping and re-covering a whole slope or more changes more than 50% of the roof, which is past that point with either covering. If you stay with slate, the guide to re-slating a roof takes you through the job.
Myth
Swapping like for like means building control never gets involved.
Fact
A full re-cover affects more than 50% of the roof, outside the Planning Portal's no-application test.
Lifespans, each in its source's own words
Lifespans come as approximations and should be read that way. HomeBuilding (last updated 30 September 2025) lists Welsh slate at 100+ years, Spanish slate at 75-100 years, reclaimed Welsh slate at 50-80 years, clay tiles at 60-80 years and plain concrete tiles at 40-50 years.
Marley, a tile maker, cites a BRE finding of at least 60 years for clay tiles. Across roof tiles in general it expects around 60 years, and it says that figure is no promise of how long a tile will last. The two sources disagree on concrete, Marley at around 60 years and HomeBuilding at 40-50 for plain concrete tiles. Both are set down here as published.
Neither figure is a promise about your own roof. The covering is one part of what ages. Underlay, battens, fixings, lead at the chimney and the valleys, and the gutters all wear on their own timescales, and a long-lived covering can sit on parts that need work sooner. A survey therefore looks across the whole roof and we say plainly what else we saw.
If an existing slate roof is struggling, the covering may not be the cause. Our guide to Welsh against Spanish slate describes the two stones and how each is characterised.
Approximate lifespans as published
Slate
- Welsh: 100+ years
- Spanish: 75-100 years
- Reclaimed Welsh: 50-80 years
Tiles
- Clay: 60-80 years
- Plain concrete: 40-50 years
- Marley, tiles: around 60
Appearance, listed homes and what the council can ask
Slate and tile read differently on a roof. Slate is thin, flat and fine-edged, and it lies close and even. A pantile is curved and gives the roof a rolling profile, while a plain tile is flat but thicker and shorter. A house beside neighbours who share one covering can be a reason to match it, and that is your design choice, not a rule.
Planning need not get in the way of a swap. Re-roofing a house is normally permitted development under Class C, so a covering swap need not start as a planning matter. Two things can alter that. A listed home keeps its permitted development rights for roof work, yet it needs listed building consent for work in any manner which would affect its character as a building of special architectural or historic interest. An Article 4 direction is the other thing to rule out, since it may remove rights, so ask the council about your own address. For Great Yarmouth, that is Great Yarmouth Borough Council.
Inside the Broads Authority's executive area, the Broads Authority is the local planning authority for the land. Building Regulations stay with the district council's building control team or a registered building control approver. The planning permission guide covers the planning side in full, and it is worth reading before you fall for a covering the council might query.
Working it out for your own roof
Taken together, the decision boils down to a short series of checks, and the survey does the measuring for most of them. If slate or tile is still open on your house, this order keeps the decision tied to the roof rather than to a catalogue.
Start with the pitch, since it removes some products before any other question arises. Move to the structure that has to carry the new covering, then to whether the change crosses the weight threshold, and only then to the look and the price. A WhatsApp photo of the roof is a fair opening move, though only the survey can fix the written price.
If our slate roofing work is part of what you are weighing, the survey covers the whole slope and ends with a plain account of what the structure can carry. That includes layers under the covering that a quote for slate or tile alone could leave unmentioned, such as the underlay, the battens and the lead at the chimney.
None of this needs to be settled before you call. A roof that has leaked, slipped or sagged is a good reason to get it looked at while the covering is still undecided, because what the survey finds in the structure can narrow the choice faster than any price list. Bring the question with you and the answer will be about your roof, not about roofs in general.
Working through slate or tile
- Find the pitch, because it rules some products out.
- Check the rafters and battens for what they can carry.
- Ask whether the weight change reaches 15 per cent or more.
- Check listed status, Article 4 and the Broads with the council.
- Compare quotes for the same covering, house size and scope.


