What each covering is made of
Natural slate is a metamorphic rock that splits along its grain into thin, flat plates. A quarry cuts and dresses each plate to size, and no two are quite the same thickness, shade or edge. The roof takes its character from that variation. Welsh and Spanish slate are two of the natural slates on sale, and our guide to Welsh and Spanish slate looks at the difference between them.
A fibre cement slate is a factory product. Cement and reinforcing fibres are mixed, formed into thin sheets and cut to a standard size, so every slate in a pack matches the next. It is described as a man-made or artificial slate, and makers sell it in several sizes and shades, some with a textured face that imitates split stone. The make is the reason for most of the practical differences below: a manufactured slate is uniform where a natural one is varied, and it comes with a data sheet where a natural one comes with a quarry's grading.
Slates of either kind are thin plates, laid in overlapping courses with a headlap that stops rain being driven up under them, and fixed by nails or hooks to timber battens. The underlay and battens beneath are common to both, so changing from one covering to the other swaps the top layer on the same roof structure.
Two coverings side by side
Natural slate
- Split from rock
- Varies slate to slate
- Graded by the quarry
Fibre cement
- Cement and fibre sheet
- Uniform in a pack
- Described by a data sheet
How they look on the roof and from the street
Look at a natural slate roof in different weather and the slopes change: blue-grey in rain, a lighter grey in sun, with a slight sheen where slates catch the light. The surface carries the marks of the splitting, and the edges are not perfectly straight. That irregularity is what people mean when they say a natural slate roof has depth, and that variation can be part of what gives a whole street of houses its own character.
A fibre cement roof is flatter in tone and more regular in line. Where a maker offers a textured face, the pattern repeats across the slope, which a close look from the pavement can show. From across a road the two can be hard to tell apart, but a long roof with a ridge in plain view shows the repetition.
Both coverings change colour with age, and algae or moss can settle on either. Marley's cleaning advice rules out strong jetting for slate or tile, so cleaning is a gentle job and not a blast. Whether the finished look suits the house is a judgement. It becomes a requirement only where the council, a conservation area or a listed building controls it, which later sections cover.
Lifespan: what the figures say and what they do not
For natural slate there is a published range. HomeBuilding (last updated 30 September 2025) gives approximate lifespans of 100+ years for Welsh slate, 75-100 years for Spanish slate and 50-80 years for reclaimed Welsh slate. They are approximate, they describe the slate and not the roof, and a slate that outlasts its fixings can still need re-covering. Reclaimed Welsh slate has the lowest of the three ranges.
For fibre cement slate, a lifespan is whatever the maker publishes, and it should be read with its conditions. Ask for the figure in writing, find out what it covers, and check whether it describes the slate, the roof or the product's terms, none of which is the same as how long your covering will last. Marley adds a caution to its own tile life figure: "This is not a guarantee or warranty of its longevity." The same caution suits any manufacturer's number.
The natural slate figures above come from one source and cannot be borrowed for a manufactured product. Anyone who quotes a number of years for either covering should name where it comes from. The underlay, battens, fixings, leadwork and ridge can each wear out sooner than the slates, and the survey checks every one.
Myth
A lifespan quoted for natural slate also applies to fibre cement slate.
Fact
HomeBuilding's slate ranges are for natural slate; a manufactured slate needs its maker's own figure.
Weight, fire and the Building Regulations when you change covering
Swapping one covering for another is not like-for-like, and the Building Regulations care about two things. The Planning Portal says approval is needed if "You use a new covering material which increases the weight of the roof covering by 15 per cent or more." Approved Document A treats a roof load increased by more than 15% as a significant change, and the Planning Portal says to have a structural engineer or surveyor check the roof before work begins. A covering's weight is on its data sheet, listed per square metre as laid, and the sums need doing for the actual roof.
The second check is fire. Approval is also needed if "The performance of any new covering will be significantly different to that of the existing covering in the event of a fire". A maker's data sheet states the fire classification of a covering, so a change from natural slate to a manufactured one is compared on paper before it is ordered. Neither check rules a change out. Each is a reason to settle the covering on paper, with the council's building control team or a registered building control approver, before anything is ordered.
Re-covering the whole roof sits outside the Planning Portal test for small jobs, where no building regulations application is normally needed if "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" is affected and less than 50 per cent of the roof. That holds whatever material goes back on.
Checks when changing covering
- Weight: 15 per cent or more heavier needs approval
- Fire: a significantly different performance needs approval
- Structure: engineer or surveyor checks before work
- Pitch: the maker's minimum for the product
- Fixings: nails or hooks to suit the pitch
Pitch, fixing and the maker's data sheet
Slate is not laid at any pitch. Cupa reports that BS 5534 "also indicates that the minimum roof pitch for natural slate is 20 degrees in the case of a project situated in an area with moderate exposure and with a slate 500mm long and a 115mm overlap". The same source rules out hook fixings on any pitch below 25º. Those are natural slate figures, tied to one slate size and one overlap.
A manufactured slate has its own minimum pitch and its own headlap, set by the maker for each product, and it is read from the product sheet and not carried over from natural slate. Marley does the same with tiles: it lists a different minimum for each product, from 12.5 degrees up to 40 degrees depending on the tile. The lesson is the same for slates. A shallower roof than the sheet allows lets rain run back up under the slate in driving weather, so a low pitch can rule one product out even when the look is right. Our guide to slate roof costs shows how that choice feeds into price.
Fixing follows the roof's exposure. BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 is the current British Standard for fixing slates and tiles. Marley notes that following BS 5534 isn't required by law, yet a roof's fixing specification is site specific and allows for its exposure. Nails and hooks both have their place, and a replacement covering is fixed in the way the product sheet and the pitch require.
Choosing a covering for the pitch
- Measure the roof pitch
- Read each product's minimum pitch and headlap
- Rule out anything the pitch does not allow
- Check weight and fire against the existing covering
- Then compare look and cost
What the published prices say
Pricing a fibre cement roof waits for the survey, like any roof, and the written quote names the covering. The natural slate figures below give a sense of scale, each with its source and date. MyJobQuote (page dated 6 October 2026) gives an average of around £7,800 for fitting a slate roof. HomeBuilding (last updated 30 September 2025) says a standard three-bedroom semi with a 65m2 roof and plain concrete tiles may cost between £10,000 and £15,000, and says the Welsh slate version of that property might reach £18,000.
Those figures are for particular houses and particular coverings, and a different roof has a different total. Checkatrade (June 2026) gives around £190 per m² for natural slate repairs, excluding VAT; a per m² figure is a rate for repair work, not a total for a roof, and the roof's size and access set the sum. Which? Trusted Traders put replacing the whole roof of an average three-bedroom house at £7,000 to £21,000 excluding VAT (survey of 11 traders, November 2025). Roof size, access, sound or rotten battens and whatever the slates are hiding all move the price more than the slate choice alone. Where the survey finds timber that needs replacing, that sits inside the same written total, which is why two quotes for the same roof can only be compared if each says what the covering, fixings and timber repairs are.
Our written quote is one total price after the survey, so two coverings can be set against each other on the same roof. Ask for each covering to be named, with its fixing method and data sheet, so you know what you are comparing.
Published slate-related figures
| Fitting a slate roof, average (MyJobQuote) | average around £7,800 |
|---|---|
| Plain concrete tile re-roof, 65m2 semi (HomeBuilding) | may cost £10,000 to £15,000 |
| Welsh slate re-roof, same property (HomeBuilding) | might reach £18,000 |
| Replacing entire roof (Which?) | £7,000 to £21,000 ex VAT (average three-bedroom house) |
MyJobQuote page dated 6 October 2026, no VAT basis stated. HomeBuilding last updated 30 September 2025. Which? Trusted Traders survey of 11 traders, November 2025, excluding VAT.
Conservation areas, listed homes and older fibre cement
A conservation area is article 2(3) land, which removes the Class B right to enlarge a roof, but Class C has no such exclusion. Re-roofing a house is normally permitted development under Class C, so the designation alone does not stop a change of covering. Two things can. An Article 4 direction can take permitted development rights away within a mapped area, and the council holds the list, so check with your council whether one covers your street before you choose a covering. Listed status adds a second layer, because consent covers anything done "in any manner which would affect its character as a building of special architectural or historic interest". A roof covering can be part of that character.
A council protecting the look of a street may ask for the material already on the roof. What it requires is for the council to say, so ask it, in writing if you can, before a covering is ordered. Our guide to slate roofs in conservation areas goes into that side of the question.
One more reason to look hard at an old fibre cement roof. HSE says: "If the building was built or refurbished before 2000, assume that there is asbestos in it", and asbestos cement roof sheeting is one of the materials it names. Do not drill, break, scrub or pressure wash a roof of unknown age. Careful removal of intact asbestos cement without breaking it up is non-licensed work, damaged or broken-up material is notifiable, and HSE says to use a lockable skip for asbestos. The survey of the roof comes first, and our slate roofing pages cover the wider range of slate work.


