The short answer
Yes, a roof window can be replaced with one of equal size without touching the rafters, as long as the new frame matches the old opening. The flashing is renewed with it, and the new unit has to meet the heat-loss limit in Approved Document L. A swap costs less than cutting a new opening.
Reading the size code
Roof windows are made in fixed sizes, and each maker names them with a short code for the width and length of the frame. A sticker or stamp carrying the code may be on the frame edge or the side of the sash, so open the window and look around it. If time or paint has taken it off, the frame can be measured instead.
Take the measurement across the outside of the frame, where it meets the covering. The glass visible from the room is smaller than the frame, and a window ordered from those figures would be too small for the hole. Record the width and the length, and note which way the roof slopes so the two numbers do not get swapped.
The maker's list then gives the nearest code. If your figures sit between two sizes, the smaller is the one that fits the opening, and the larger would mean widening it, which is a new opening. Our guide to Velux-type window replacement sets out the wider job.
Pitch, style and glazing to match
Size is only the first match. The new window also has to suit the roof's pitch, copy the way the old one opened and fit the finish on the room side. A window of the right size with the wrong hinge style is a different product, because frames and sashes cannot be mixed between types.
- Frame size, by code or by measurement.
- Pitch range the unit is designed for.
- Opening style: top-hung, centre-pivot or fixed.
- Covering the flashing is shaped for, whether tile, pantile or slate.
- Glazing: toughened or laminated, double or triple.
If you change the opening style, check it against the room, because a pivot sash swings its lower half indoors and whatever stands under it must clear the swing. Our page on top-hung or centre-pivot compares them.
Glazing is the last match. A pane that is laminated, or built up as a double or triple unit, changes how the window sounds in rain, how it holds heat and what it costs. Replacing like with like keeps the room as it is, whereas a change of glass is a chance to improve it, so settle it before ordering, since the glass cannot be changed on site afterwards.
Can the old flashing be reused?
Reusing it would put worn metal and seals next to a brand-new window, so the answer is to renew it. Flashing is cut for one frame size and one covering, and it has aged in step with the window it surrounds. A leak at the first joint would then sit right next to the new glass.
The covering matters here. Pieces made for plain tiles do not follow the deep waves of a pantile, and a slate roof needs a different shape again. If the roof was recovered after the first window went in, what is round the opening today may not be what the old flashing was made for, so identify the covering before ordering.
With the old frame out, the wood around the opening can be inspected. Stained or soft battens and rafter sides mark a place where moisture has been getting in, and it is far easier to deal with that now than after the new frame has been screwed down. The skylights and roof windows page lists the related jobs.
Limits, checks and price
A new roof window is building work, so it meets today's figure even when the one it replaces did not. Approved Document L 2021 Table 4.2 gives 1.4 W/m²K, or at least Band B on the WER scale, for a roof window going into an existing dwelling, with 2.2 W/m²K set for a rooflight. The two categories differ, so confirm which one the unit you want falls into.
Whether the swap has to be notified depends on the work and the address, so ask your council's building control team, or a registered building control approver, before ordering. A unit that misses the limit cannot be treated as an ordinary swap, which is a reason to ask early.
MyJobQuote's roof window page, updated 22 September 2026, gives £1,100 as the average cost of a mid-range Velux window and says replacing one costs around £100 less where the opening is already there. The total for this swap is written down after a visit to the roof. Our guide to Building Regulations for roof windows covers the rules.


