The short answer
On a full re-roof the battens are checked as the old covering comes off, and they are replaced where they are rotten, split or set to the wrong gauge. A new tile with its own fixed gauge, such as Sandtoft's 290 mm pantile figure, can mean new battens across the whole roof.
Why a strip shows what a survey cannot
Battens are narrow lengths of timber nailed across the rafters, and the tiles hang from them. From the loft they are partly hidden by the underlay, and from the ground they cannot be seen at all. A full re-roof removes the covering, so for once each batten can be inspected end to end rather than guessed at from a few lifted tiles.
That is the moment to judge them. A batten can look sound and still be split where a nail was driven, soft where damp has sat against it, or marked by old fixings. Underlay and covering are being renewed during the same job, so replacing a doubtful length is simple while the roof is open and a far bigger task once new tiles are down on top of it.
- Rot and softness: dark timber that gives under a thumbnail.
- Splits at nail holes, which let a fixing pull out.
- Old nail holes in a pattern that no longer matches the new spacing.
- Sag between rafters, which shows as a wave in the roof line.
When a new gauge forces new battens
A tile is made for a particular batten spacing. The maker's data sheet for Sandtoft's clay pantile lists "Batten spacing (fixed gauge)" of 290mm, a headlap of 75mm and a minimum roof pitch of 30°. Laying that pantile means working to the 290mm spacing, with its headlap.
Battens set out for the old tiles reflect the old tile. If the new product has a different gauge, the old timber is in the wrong places and cannot be shuffled along, because the old nail holes would still be in it and the lengths would be crowded. In that case every batten is replaced, even where the timber is sound, because a roof laid to a mixture of spacings would leave some courses with the wrong headlap. A tile whose gauge is not fixed gives the roofer a little room to set the spacing along the slope, within the limits on the product sheet, which is one reason to read that sheet before ordering anything.
| Situation | Battens |
|---|---|
| New tile has a different gauge | New timber, set to the new spacing |
| Same gauge, timber sound | Reuse can be considered after checking |
| Rot or splits found | Replace the affected lengths or the lot |
Reusing battens: the argument and the risk
Reuse sounds like a saving, and in a few cases it is a fair one. If the old tile and the new tile have the same gauge, and every length has been checked and is sound, there is no technical reason to bin good timber. The word that matters is every. One weak batten can let a fixing pull out, and a tile that slips leaves the underlay exposed.
The saving also has a price in inspection, since every length along a whole slope has to be examined. Reused timber carries the old nail holes too, and a nail driven into a hole that has already been used holds less well.
Marley says that BS 5534 is a code of practice, not law, but since its 2015 amendments mortar alone is no longer relied on to secure the roof covering. Tiles are held by nails and clips driven into the battens, so the timber has to hold a fixing for decades. Good fixings in tired timber are a weak combination.
What a quote should say about battens
A quote that says re-roof and nothing more leaves the battens undecided. Ask whether the price is for new battens or reused ones, and what gauge the chosen tile needs. Ask about the timber too: its size depends on how far apart the rafters are and how heavy the tile is, so a figure copied from another roof is a poor guide, and a firm that has measured yours can say what it will fit. If the figure depends on what the strip finds, ask how a change will be put to you before work goes on.
At Total Roofing Great Yarmouth the survey takes in the timber as well as the covering. Anything it turns up is described in simple terms, alongside one written total price for the roof as it stands.
Our re-roofing process guide shows where the battens come in the order of work, and choosing a new roof covering explains why the tile sets the spacing. Both belong to roof replacement.


