Call 01493 277103

Pitched roofing

Pantiles or Plain Tiles?

Pantiles and plain tiles are laid differently, look different and ask different things of the roof. This page covers how they compare on lapping, pitch, weight, appearance and what drives the cost.

Get a written quote

Call 01493 277103WhatsApp us

Old corrugated sheet roof on a rendered garage beside houses

The short answer

A pantile is a large S-shaped tile laid in a single lap, so each tile covers more roof. Plain tiles are small and flat and go on in a double lap, so each point is covered twice. They differ in minimum pitch, weight, look and cost drivers, and the product data sheet settles the numbers.

Single lap and double lap

A pantile is a big tile, curved in an S-shape, and it is laid in what roofers call a single lap: each tile overlaps its neighbour sideways and the course below by a set headlap, and the curve carries water down the trough beside it. Plain tiles are small flat rectangles with a slight camber, laid in a double lap, so each patch of roof sits under at least two thicknesses of tile.

The difference shows in the work. A pantile roof has fewer, larger tiles to the square metre, and the roof surface reads as bold ridges and troughs. A plain tile roof has many small tiles in tight rows, and the surface reads as fine and even. Neither is better in the abstract: each is a way of keeping rain out, and each asks the roof for different things.

Our guide to what a pantile roof is and the one on plain tile roofs each go through how their tile is built and laid.

Pitch and weight

Every tile has a minimum pitch set by its maker. Sandtoft puts the minimum pitch of its clay Old English Pantile at 30 degrees, with a 75 mm headlap. On Marley's list the Lincoln clay pantile needs 15 degrees and the concrete Anglia 25 degrees, while Marley's concrete plain tile needs 35 degrees. These are product figures, so a different maker's tile needs its own sheet checked.

Weight is the other number. Sandtoft's sheet for the same pantile reads 41.6 kg per m² as laid. A plain tile's weight comes from its own maker's sheet, so a swap from one to the other is judged against the old covering's data sheet and the new covering's. The Planning Portal says a new covering which increases the roof's weight by "15 per cent or more" needs Building Regulations approval.

Pitch is a limit. A roof laid at a shallow pitch can take a pantile that is made for it, but not a plain tile that needs a steeper angle, and the rafters set the angle. A change of tile type on an existing roof is therefore a question of pitch first and appearance second.

Pantile or plain tile

Pantile

  • Large S-shaped tile
  • Single lap
  • Bold ridges and troughs
  • Fewer tiles per m²

Plain tile

  • Small flat tile
  • Double lap
  • Fine even surface
  • Many tiles per m²

Look and local character

The look is a large part of the choice. A pantile roof gives a rolling, rippled skyline, and a plain tile roof gives a flat, finely textured one. Neighbouring roofs, the age of the house and any council view of the street all bear on which suits the address. A house in a conservation area, or a listed one, can face limits on changing the covering, and we check with the council whether an Article 4 direction applies before a tile is chosen.

Materials matter to the look too. Either shape can be had in clay or in concrete, and the two materials weather differently, with clay taking on a mellower finish over time and concrete holding its factory colour. The sample laid next to the existing tiles in daylight tells you more than a catalogue photograph.

If you are weighing the materials as well as the shapes, our guide to clay and concrete pantiles sets the two side by side.

What drives the cost of each

The tile is only one part of the price. The roof area, the pitch, the access, the condition of the battens and underlay and any chimney or valley work all move the total. Plain tiles mean more pieces to lay on the same area, and a pantile means fewer larger ones, but the piece count says little about the price until the roof has been surveyed.

Lifespan figures also belong in the picture. HomeBuilding (last updated 30 September 2025) gives approximate lifespans of 60 to 80 years for clay tiles and 40 to 50 years for plain concrete tiles. For a whole new roof, Which? Trusted Traders give £7,000 to £21,000 for an average three-bedroom house, excluding VAT (November 2025), and HomeBuilding's example is a three-bedroom semi, standard, with 65m2 of roof and plain concrete tiles, which it says may cost between £10,000 and £15,000.

Your own figure follows the survey. The pitched roofing page covers the tiled roof work we do.

Questions and answers

Can plain tiles replace pantiles on the same roof?

Only if the pitch, the structure and the planning position allow it. The roof's angle has to be at or above the new tile's minimum, the weight is checked against the Planning Portal's 15 per cent or more test, and a listed or conservation-area address may need consent. Each is settled before a tile is chosen.

Which is lighter, a pantile or a plain tile?

The Sandtoft clay Old English Pantile weighs 41.6 kg per m² as laid, by its own sheet. A plain tile's weight depends on the maker, the material and the laying, so the data sheets for the two products are read side by side. Do not rely on the shape of the tile to judge it.

Does the single lap or double lap keep rain out better?

Both do the job when they are laid within the maker's pitch and headlap. A single-lap tile relies on its profile and headlap to shed water. A double-lap tile relies on overlapping courses. The choice of lapping matters less than whether pitch, battens, underlay and fixings suit the tile on the roof.

Get a written quote

Tell us about your roof

Hand dressing a lead ridge roll with a wooden bossing stick

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing

Call WhatsApp Written quote