Call 01493 277103

Pitched roofing

How to Match Old Roof Tiles

Matching an old roof tile means getting the profile, size, material and weathering close enough to sit with the tiles around it. Here are the checks, and where a matching tile can come from.

Get a written quote

Call 01493 277103WhatsApp us

A stack of new clay plain tiles on a scaffold board

The short answer

Match old tiles by measuring and comparing: the profile, the length and width, the material and the colour. Where a new tile is too bright, a reclaimed one or one taken from a hidden slope will blend better. Pitch, headlap and batten gauge must also suit the tile you fit.

Profile, size and material

Two tiles can look alike from the street and still differ once you hold them. The first check is the profile: pantile, plain tile, double Roman, interlocking and other shapes each lap differently, and a wrong-profile tile will not bed down against its neighbours. The second is size. Length and width decide how far each tile overlaps the one below and how many fit in a course, so a tile a few millimetres out can leave a gap or a ridge in the line of the roof.

The material is the third check. Pantiles and other shapes are made in clay as well as concrete, and the two weather differently. A clay tile and a concrete tile of the same shape and nearly the same colour will not age alike, and the difference shows after a few winters. Where a roof has already been patched with a mix of tiles, the survey notes which ones are original before matching begins.

A broken tile can be measured and photographed, and a picture sent on WhatsApp, 07880 284133, helps us judge what we are matching before we are on the roof.

Pitch, headlap and gauge

Looking the same is not enough, because every tile type has its own working rules. Take Sandtoft's clay Old English Pantile: 30 degrees is its minimum pitch, 75 mm its headlap, and 290 mm its fixed batten gauge. Marley's product list shows 15 degrees for the Lincoln clay pantile against 25 degrees for the concrete Anglia. A substitute that needs a steeper pitch than the roof has will let rain through, however well it matches.

Batten gauge matters for a patch because the new tile hangs from the existing battens. If its length differs from the old tile's, its lugs may not land on the batten at the right spacing, and the tile either rides up or leaves a gap. This is why we measure rather than eyeball the sizes.

  • Profile and the way it laps
  • Length, width and thickness
  • Clay or concrete
  • Minimum pitch for the product
  • Batten gauge and headlap

The detail of pitch and lap for pantiles is in our guide to pantile pitch and headlap, and plain tiles are covered in plain tile roofs.

Reclaimed or new, and the hidden slope

New tiles are made to a current specification and arrive with the surface of a day-old tile. Reclaimed tiles come off another building and carry decades of weathering, which is the strongest argument for them on a roof where the colour has to read as one. Their drawback is the condition. A reclaimed tile may have a cracked or frost-damaged face, so each one is sorted before it goes up.

A third source is the roof itself. Where one slope cannot be seen from the road, a few sound tiles can be lifted from there and put on the visible slope, and new tiles laid on the hidden side instead. The mismatch moves to where nobody looks, and the front keeps its weathered finish. The loft and the rear slope are checked first so that no weak point is created.

None of these routes is free of trade-offs. HomeBuilding gives approximate lifespans of 60 to 80 years for clay tiles and 40 to 50 years for plain concrete tiles (last updated 30 September 2025), and a reclaimed tile has already used part of its life, so the survey weighs that against the look. You hear what we found and decide.

Myth

Any tile of the same colour will do for a repair.

Fact

Profile, size, material, pitch and batten gauge all have to suit as well.

When matching fails, and what it costs

Sometimes no match exists. The profile may have gone out of production, or the weathered colour cannot be found. The choices are then a visible patch, a run of new tiles across the damaged area chosen to sit as quietly as possible, or a re-cover of the whole slope so the roof reads as one. Our pitched roofing page covers the wider re-roofing work.

On cost, Which? Trusted Traders give £75 to £400 when one to six standard tiles on a roof are broken or missing, excluding VAT (November 2025). That range is for standard tiles. A tile that has to be sourced, sorted and cut to blend in is a different job, and MyJobQuote gives around £650 as the average for a roof repair (6 October 2026).

What yours costs depends on the roof's tile, its access and the number of tiles, and the figure comes after the survey. See pitched roof repair cost for the other published figures.

Questions and answers

Can I take a spare tile from the garage roof?

You can try, provided it is the same tile. Compare the profile, the length and the thickness against the roof you are patching, and check the pitch it was laid at, because a different roof may have used a different product. Even a match that fits the roof in size can differ in colour, so the survey looks at the tile in daylight.

Will a new tile always look different?

Fresh from the kiln or the mould, a tile will stand out against weathered neighbours, and the colour gap closes with the seasons. Reclaimed tiles close the gap at once but carry the risk of damage. Which route to take is a choice we set out after the survey, with what each one does to the look of the roof.

Does matching matter if the roof is not on show?

The fit matters whether or not anyone sees it, because a tile of the wrong size or pitch can let water in. The colour matters less on a hidden slope, and that is where a mismatch can be placed. A tile that suits the roof's working rules is the first requirement, and the look is the second.

Get a written quote

Tell us about your roof

Hand dressing a lead ridge roll with a wooden bossing stick

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing

Call WhatsApp Written quote