The short answer
Sometimes, if the sheets are sound enough to carry a new covering and the fixings go in without breaking them. HSE calls asbestos cement roofs fragile, and broken sheeting is a different category of work from intact sheeting, so the roof has to be looked at before anyone commits.
What overlaying means on a garage
To overlay a roof is to lay a new covering on top of the existing one instead of stripping the old one off. On a garage with corrugated asbestos cement sheets, the sheets stay where they are and a new weatherproof layer goes over them, carried on a supporting structure of its own.
The attraction is plain. Nothing has to be lifted off, packaged and disposed of now, which spares the removal cost and the disposal rules for the moment. MyJobQuote's average for taking asbestos off a roof is around £2,750 (9 September 2026), and the Norfolk and Suffolk disposal rules, set out on our page on asbestos disposal in Norfolk and Suffolk, add their own complications.
The price of that saving is that the sheets are still asbestos cement. The roof carries on being a building you must treat as containing asbestos, and the question of what to do with the material is passed to whoever owns the garage later.
Fragile sheets and the fixing problem
HSE's guidance calls asbestos cement roofs "always fragile". Whatever goes on top needs fixing down, and here the fixings either pass through the old sheets or land on a framework laid across them. Every hole drilled through a sheet and every foot that lands between supports risks cracking it.
This is where the HSE tiers come in. HSE puts carefully handled, unbroken asbestos cement in the non-licensed tier, and puts sheeting that has been badly damaged or crushed into notifiable non-licensed work. An overlay that cracks the sheets does not just create a mess. It can change which tier the work belongs in, and with it the duties that apply. We do not drill into asbestos cement on the strength of a guess about the material.
That is why condition comes before everything else. Sheets that are weathered but whole stand a better chance of taking an overlay than sheets already cracked, crumbling or fire damaged. The survey also asks what the roof is made from, what carries it, and how the sheets are holding together, since only testing confirms asbestos cement. Our answer on whether removing asbestos roof sheets is illegal lays out the tiers.
Weight, fire and Building Regulations
A second covering adds load to a roof that was not designed with it in mind. The Planning Portal's guidance on re-roofing asks for Building Regulations approval when a new covering adds weight to the roof covering, by "15 per cent or more", and when the new covering would perform in a significantly different way in a fire. It also recommends asking a structural engineer or a surveyor to look first.
Approved Document A treats a roof load increased by more than 15% as a significant change. Both tests are about the covering, and an overlay keeps the old one and adds a new one, so it is the sum that matters. We check the planning or building control route with the council before work starts. Whether an overlay is workable depends on the survey and the structural check, and no general rule settles it.
Published figures for the new covering start with MyJobQuote's garage roof replacement average of £750 to £3,500 (26 October 2026), which states no VAT basis. Which? gives felt and EPDM ranges for a 6m x 3m garage (November 2025, excluding VAT). Those are replacement figures, so an overlay needs its own price.
What stays once the new roof is on
- The asbestos remains, so removal is still ahead, under the same disposal rules, at an average of around £2,750 for taking asbestos off a roof, according to MyJobQuote (9 September 2026).
- A buyer's surveyor will still see asbestos cement under the new covering, so a sale is not made simpler by hiding it. Our answer on selling a house with an asbestos garage roof covers that side.
- Any later repair or replacement has to deal with two roofs rather than one.
Overlaying is not a bad idea, only a trade-off. A sound garage that the owner plans to keep for years may suit it, and a roof with cracked sheets or a sale on the horizon may point towards removal instead. The flat roofing hub covers the new coverings you could choose from.
A photo on WhatsApp to 07880 284133 helps us see the sheeting. Once we have surveyed, the work we advise comes to you priced as one written total.


