The short answer
Not in itself. HSE puts asbestos cement roof sheeting in its non-licensed tier when it is lifted off whole and carefully handled. Sheets that are cracked up or crushed move into a notification tier, and most work on asbestos insulating board needs a licence.
HSE's three tiers for roof asbestos
HSE does not ask whether removal is allowed. It asks what the material is, what condition it is in and how long the job lasts, then puts the work in one of three tiers. Each tier carries different duties.
| Material and condition | HSE tier |
|---|---|
| Asbestos cement roof sheets lifted off intact, weathered ones included if they are not badly damaged | Non-licensed work |
| Asbestos cement sheets that are badly damaged or already in pieces, such as after a fire or a flood | Notifiable non-licensed work, shortened to NNLW |
| Asbestos insulating board where the assessment of risk shows the job is not brief | Licensed work |
Asbestos insulating board, or AIB, is a different material from the corrugated sheets on a garage. HSE names "AIB white soffit panels to underside of roof eaves" among its locations, so a house roof can hold both materials. Whichever tier applies, board that falls in the licensed tier is work for a firm that holds the licence, and a roofer without one should leave it alone. The tier is set by the material and the job, not by the trade of whoever is on the roof.
Why the condition of the sheets matters
HSE's rule of thumb for age is: "If the building was built or refurbished before 2000, assume that there is asbestos in it." That can take in a garage or outbuilding roofed in cement sheeting. Testing, not appearance, establishes whether a particular sheet is asbestos cement.
A sheet that has weathered, gone mossy or lost its surface stays in the first tier, provided it has not been badly damaged. A sheet cracked through by a fallen branch, or scorched in a fire, does not. The gap between the first tier and the second is the gap between a sheet that comes off in one piece and one that is already in fragments.
HSE adds a plain warning in its guidance on cement roofs: "AC roofs are always fragile". That matters before anyone climbs up, because a boot or a ladder foot placed on a sheet can break it. Our answer on overlaying an asbestos garage roof covers the alternative of leaving the sheets where they are.
What becomes of the sheets afterwards
Getting the sheets down is half the story, because the material then has to go somewhere. HSE's instruction for the container is short and specific: "Use a lockable skip for asbestos". It also says that draping sheeting over a standard skip is inadequate.
The waste paperwork has its own twist. The government's consignment note exemption lets a householder move domestic hazardous waste to an initial collection point, but only waste "other than asbestos waste". Whoever carries waste has to be registered as a carrier, either upper tier or lower tier.
The recycling centres offer no easy answer in either county. Norfolk County Council states: "We do not accept any type of asbestos at any of our recycling centres", hazardous waste events included. Suffolk's wording is that "you cannot take it to any Suffolk Recycling Centre", and the county council runs a paid collection, through its contractor, of small household amounts of cement bonded sheeting. Our page on asbestos disposal in Norfolk and Suffolk sets out each county's rule.
Where a roofer fits in
A roof with asbestos sheeting is still a roof, and the first step is finding out what the covering is and what condition it is in. We survey before we quote, covering every slope, and say plainly what we see, including any sign that the sheeting or the soffit boards might be asbestos. A photo sent on WhatsApp to 07880 284133 is a fair start, though only testing settles the material.
If the sheeting is damaged, or the soffit board proves to be insulating board, the work moves into the tiers above that are notifiable or licensed. HSE's own pages spell out what each tier involves, and the notifiable tier has its own steps before work begins. Norfolk County Council's own advice is to use a licenced specialist contractor to remove and dispose of all types of asbestos. Put the question to any firm you are weighing: which HSE tier do they place your roof in, and why?
For everything else about replacing a garage or flat roof, the flat roofing hub is the place to begin, and selling a house with an asbestos garage roof covers what a sale adds.


