The short answer
The lowest sound route depends on what the garage roof is made of and what state it is in. Which? puts felt on a single 6m x 3m garage at £1,400 to £3,500 excluding VAT (November 2025). MyJobQuote's average roof repair is around £650 (page dated 6 October 2026).
Where repair, felt and rubber sit on published figures
The routes below are ordered by the size of the job, not by merit. Every row carries the page it came from, because the sources measure different things and none of them has seen your garage.
| Route | Figure | Source and date |
|---|---|---|
| Roof repair | an average of around £650 | MyJobQuote, 6 October 2026. |
| Felt, single garage 6m x 3m | £1,400 to £3,500 | Which?, November 2025, ex VAT. |
| EPDM with new boards, same garage | £1,950 to £4,000 | Which?, November 2025, ex VAT. |
| Rubber roof, fully installed | an average of £1,050 | MyJobQuote, 9 October 2026. |
The repair figure covers roof repairs in general rather than a garage in particular, so it shows the scale of a small job without saying that a garage can be mended for that sum. MyJobQuote states no VAT basis on either of its figures. The flat roofing hub explains how each covering is laid and when a repair stops being realistic, and the point at which a repair only delays the bill is hard to judge from a price guide.
Setting lifespan beside price
A lower sum today can come with a shorter published life, so look at both columns before you decide. HomeBuilding gives torch-on felt 10-15 years and EPDM 25-30; Less gives felt 10 to 20 and EPDM 30 to 50, and says felt lasts that long "depending on quality and installation". The two guides were last updated on 30 September 2025 and 9 November 2026 respectively.
Put beside Which?'s figures, felt carries the lower price and the shorter range, while EPDM with new boards carries the higher price and the longer one. That is a comparison of published numbers, not a promise about your roof, and neither guide says how long a given garage will actually last. A garage with a good deck and tidy edges has more to give a new covering than one with neither, which is why the survey looks at the parts around the membrane as well as the membrane.
The Which? EPDM figure is for a roof with new boards. If your deck is sound and stays, the work may differ from what that figure describes, and a price that is silent on the boards leaves a big question unanswered. Ask whether the deck is renewed or kept, and what the decision rests on.
Asbestos cement sheets change the options
A corrugated garage roof built or refurbished before 2000 may be asbestos cement, and HSE tells owners to "assume that there is asbestos in it" for such buildings. HSE treats asbestos cement roof sheeting as non-licensed work when the sheets come off whole and unbroken, and its guidance adds that "AC roofs are always fragile". Standing on one is a risk in itself.
That leaves two broad routes, and neither is the do-it-yourself saving it can look like. Taking the sheets off whole and replacing them carries a published average of around £2,750 for asbestos removal from a roof (MyJobQuote, 9 September 2026), plus the cost of the new covering. Covering them in place avoids that removal for now, and our answer on overlaying an asbestos garage roof sets out what that involves.
Disposal rules differ between Norfolk and Suffolk. Norfolk County Council does not accept any asbestos at its recycling centres, and Suffolk's own page says you cannot take it to any Suffolk Recycling Centre. Our page on asbestos disposal in Norfolk and Suffolk gives each county's rule.
Savings that cost more later
- Covering a roof without checking the deck. New membrane laid over boards that are soft or damp is paying for a roof that fails early.
- Patching a roof that has no life left. One small repair can be sensible, but a run of them is a replacement paid in instalments.
- Breaking asbestos cement sheets to save disposal money, which turns careful removal into the damaged-sheeting category HSE treats separately.
- Comparing two quotes without comparing what they cover: the membrane, the boards, the edge trims and the old material.
When you ask us for a price, the survey comes first and takes in the entire roof, so the quote reflects what is really up there. You are then holding one written total to weigh against anyone else's, with anything extra we noticed named plainly, such as a split in a trim or a damp board. The garage roof replacement cost answer goes through the same published ranges at more length.


