Two systems, two questions
A roof job can fall under planning, under Building Regulations, under both or under neither. Planning looks at what the finished roof looks like and how large it is, and our guide to planning permission for roof work covers it. Building Regulations look at how the work is built: whether the structure carries the load, whether the new roof performs in a fire as the old one did, and how much heat escapes through it.
The two systems do not agree with each other on thresholds. A re-roof that needs no planning application can still need a Building Regulations application, and the reverse can also be true. Keeping them apart saves a lot of confusion when two quotes disagree about what paperwork the job needs.
Building control is the body that checks the second system. In England it is carried out by the council's building control team or by a registered building control approver. The registration regime for private approvers began on 6 April 2024, and private building control itself was already operating before that date. Whichever body takes the job, the standard it applies is the same set of regulations, so the choice between them is about service and certificates, not about a different rulebook.
Every roof is surveyed ahead of any price being written, and the survey covers every slope, not only the one that leaks. The building control route is then checked with the council before work starts, because the answer depends on the address and on the extent of the work. Start from the Total Roofing Great Yarmouth home page if you want the full picture of what we do.
The re-roofing test: two limits, both measured
For re-roofing, the Planning Portal names two conditions that must both be met before it says no application is normally needed: "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope' (walls, floor, roof, windows, door, roof windows and roof-lights) is affected", and "Less than 50 per cent of the roof is affected."
The first limit is measured against the whole shell of the building: walls, floor, roof, windows and doors together. The second is measured against the roof alone, so a re-roof is judged against its own surface as well as against the house. Both figures are limits on what is touched, and both have to hold. A homeowner comparing two quotes can ask each firm which parts of the roof it plans to strip, because the answer decides whether either limit is in play, and the firm that has surveyed every slope is the one that can answer.
| Work | Roof affected | Application normally needed? |
|---|---|---|
| Replace a few slipped tiles | A small patch | No, if the covering is the same weight |
| Re-cover one slope of a two-slope roof | About half or more | Check with building control |
| Strip and re-cover the whole roof | More than 50 per cent | Yes, outside the test |
Stripping a whole roof touches more than half of it, so that job sits outside the test no matter what the new covering is made from. Like-for-like is an idea for small repairs. None of the councils in this part of Norfolk and Suffolk has a stricter threshold on any page read for this guide, so the Planning Portal test applies, and building control has the last word on a borderline job.
Myth
Re-roofing like for like never needs Building Regulations.
Fact
A whole new covering affects more than 50 per cent of the roof, so it is outside the no-application test.
When the new covering is heavier
The Planning Portal gives a second trigger for approval, separate from the two area limits. It applies if "You use a new covering material which puts 15 per cent or more of extra weight on the roof covering." A change in fire behaviour is the other: the Portal lists "The performance of any new covering will be significantly different to that of the existing covering in the event of a fire".
Approved Document A, the structural volume, words it differently. It treats a significant change in roof loading as the point where "the loading upon the roof is increased by more than 15%". The Portal says "15 per cent or more" and Approved Document A says "more than 15%", so the two are quoted as they stand. The safe course is to treat the figure as a trigger and ask building control about any new covering that may be heavier.
The Planning Portal also advises that you "check with a structural engineer or surveyor before commencing with works" when a heavier covering is planned. The rafters, purlins and walls were sized for the old load, and a covering heavier by that margin can ask more of them than they can carry.
The figure that matters is the weight of the actual product laid on the actual roof, so compare data sheets rather than material names. One example: Sandtoft gives its clay Old English Pantile as 41.6 kg per m² as laid, which is one product's figure, and any other pantile, slate or concrete tile carries its own on its own sheet.
Questions to put to building control
- What is the as-laid weight of the new covering?
- What was the weight of the old one?
- Does the fire performance change?
- Does a structural check apply to this roof?
- How much of the roof is being renewed?
Insulation and Part L
Approved Document L, the energy volume, applies when a roof is renovated. The 2021 edition for England sets limits for new fabric and for existing elements. In Table 4.2 a new roof has a U-value of 0.15 W/(m²·K), a replacement roof window must achieve 1.4 or Window Energy Rating Band B minimum, and a rooflight must achieve 2.2. Band B is the floor, not a ranking.
Table 4.3 deals with existing elements. A roof carries a threshold of 0.35 and an improved figure of 0.16. Paragraph 11.3 sets the trigger: renovate more than 50% of the surface of an individual thermal element, here the roof, and the whole of it is improved where feasible. Paragraph 11.2(d) counts "Replacing the waterproof membrane on a flat roof" as renovation, so a flat roof re-covering is included.
The upgrade is required where it is feasible. Paragraph 4.13 gives the fallback. If the full figure cannot be reached in practice, or would take longer than 15 years to pay back through saved energy, the roof is taken as far as is feasible within a 15-year simple payback.
In practice a strip-and-re-cover job on a pitched roof is the moment to ask what insulation is in the loft and whether the new work reaches the figure. A cold roof needs ventilation and a warm roof does not, according to the CNC guide, so the insulation choice and the ventilation route are decided together. Approved Document L 2026 applies from 24 March 2027, so the 2021 figures above are the ones that stand now.
Loft conversions, chimney breasts and escape routes
A roof job that adds a room is a different category of work. Where a loft conversion creates a storey more than 4.5 m above ground, Approved Document B paragraph 2.5 calls for either a protected stairway or an alternative escape route. An escape window serves storeys up to 4.5 m above ground, so how high the new floor sits decides which route applies. Paragraph 2.23 also gives a sprinkler-based option for open-plan layouts.
A protected stairway is a stair separated from the rest of the house by fire-resisting construction. The alternative route separates the top storey from the lower ones and gives it its own way out. Neither is a detail to leave for the last week, because both change the layout of the floor below the conversion.
A chimney can bring in building control from a different direction. Removing a chimney breast always needs Building Regulations approval, the reason being that a breast forms part of the load-bearing structure of the house. It is also a matter for the neighbour if the breast is built into a party wall: the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 calls for notice of at least two months before the date the proposed work begins, and cutting a flashing into the adjoining owner's wall is party structure work with the same notice period.
Party wall questions go to a party wall surveyor, not to building control. The building owner serves the notice. A neighbour who stays silent is deemed to have dissented once the fourteen days are up, and the Act then moves the dispute to its surveyor procedure.
Order of checks for a loft room
- Measure the height of the new floor above ground.
- Choose a protected stairway or an alternative escape route.
- Check the roof window U-value against Part L.
- Ask building control before any chimney breast is cut.
- Check whether the party wall needs a notice.
Who checks the work around Great Yarmouth
The body depends on the council the address falls in. For Great Yarmouth addresses, check with Great Yarmouth Borough Council's building control team. For Lowestoft, Beccles, Southwold and the rest of East Suffolk, check with East Suffolk Council's building control team. North Norfolk District Council runs its own building control team on 01263 516345.
In South Norfolk, Broadland and Norwich, council building control is provided from its Norwich office by CNC Building Control, a partnership of five councils (South Norfolk, Norwich City, Broadland, King's Lynn & West Norfolk and Fenland). CNC Building Control can be reached on 0808 168 5041. It does not cover Great Yarmouth, North Norfolk or East Suffolk addresses.
The Broads change the planning route but not the building control route. Inside its executive area the Broads Authority decides planning, while Building Regulations stay with the district council's building control or a registered approver.
- Great Yarmouth borough: the borough council's own team
- East Suffolk: East Suffolk Council's own service
- North Norfolk: the district council's own team
- Any address: a registered building control approver is the alternative route
Our guide to roof work on a listed building adds the consent that sits on top of these checks for older homes, and the scaffolding guide covers the highway licence that applies on the street side of the job.


