The short answer
Choose fixed where the room only needs daylight and has another way to ventilate, and choose opening where you need air, a reachable outer pane or a way out. A fixed unit has no sash to open, so it cannot serve as an escape window or a means of purging heat.
What a fixed rooflight gives you
A fixed rooflight is glazing set into the roof with no hinge, no handle and no moving sash. It is a pane in a frame, sealed into the covering, and its only job is to let daylight in. Because it has fewer parts, there is less hardware to wear, less to adjust and fewer seals to fail.
That also keeps the frame slim and the view uninterrupted, which matters in a stairwell, a landing, a bathroom or a corridor where nobody wants to open anything. A fixed unit can be made to a wider or odder size than a sash window, since it does not need a mechanism and its glass is not limited by the weight of a moving part.
The trade-off is everything an opening window does. A fixed pane cannot be opened to clear steam, release warm air or let in a breeze, so the room needs another way to ventilate, such as an extractor or a window in a wall. Our guide to the types of roof window compares fixed units with the hinged and electric kinds.
What an opening rooflight adds
An opening unit does everything a fixed one does and adds a sash that moves. Opened, it ventilates the room, and in a hot spell it can let warm air out through the roof. Hinged or pivoted, it also lets a person reach the glass or step out for repairs.
- Ventilation: stale or damp air can leave, which helps a loft bedroom or a bathroom.
- Cleaning: some opening styles turn the outer face towards the room.
- Escape: a sash can serve as an emergency escape window if it meets the size figures.
- Access: a person can reach the outer glass or the roof near the window.
The price of those benefits is more parts and a larger frame. A sash needs seals all the way round, hardware that carries its weight, and a handle or control, and each of those can wear or stick. On an electric or solar model the motor and the rain sensor add further parts that a fixed window simply does not have.
Where fixed does not work
Escape is the clearest limit. Approved Document B Volume 1 describes an emergency escape window as one with an openable area of at least 0.33 m², at least 450 mm high and 450 mm wide, with its lower edge no higher than 1100 mm from the floor. A fixed pane has no openable area, so it counts for nothing here, and a loft bedroom needs a different escape arrangement if the window cannot open.
A side slope brings another rule. GOV.UK's technical guidance says a roof window on a side-elevation slope must be obscure-glazed and non-opening unless the opening part is more than 1.7 metres above the floor of the room in which the window is installed. A fixed unit meets the non-opening limb by design, but it still has to be obscure-glazed.
Cleaning is the last limit. A fixed pane cannot be turned inwards, so its outer face has to be reached from outside. Out of reach, it gets cleaned by a person on the roof or at a ladder, or it is left. Our page on cleaning roof windows goes through the options.
What drives the cost
The same frame size can price differently depending on the build, and the gap between fixed and opening is only one factor. Glazing specification, size, the flashing kit for the covering, whether the roof needs scaffold for access and the finish inside all move the figure. A fixed unit has no mechanism to pay for, but it can carry large glass, which adds its own cost.
MyJobQuote's roof window page, last updated 22 September 2026, lists £1,100 as the average cost of a mid-range Velux unit. That is one published average for one maker's range and does not split fixed from opening.
Approved Document L 2021 Table 4.2 gives a roof window one limit and a rooflight another, 1.4 W/m²K or Window Energy Rating Band B for the first and 2.2 W/m²K for the second. Which line a particular unit belongs on depends on how it is classed, so ask for the heat-loss figure on the product data. The skylights and roof windows hub sets out the other jobs that go with the glass, and one written total follows the survey.


