Four materials, and what the question really is
Four materials cover nearly every gutter you will be offered: uPVC, aluminium, cast iron and cast aluminium. The first two are what people mean by plastic and metal modern guttering. The last two are heavier cast products, made in short lengths with bolted joints, and they belong on older houses and period roof lines. The choice is not simply between plastic and metal. Each material comes with a different way of being joined, held up and finished, and those details decide how the gutter behaves once it is on the wall.
It also helps to separate two ideas that get mixed together. One is the gutter itself, the channel that catches the water. The other is everything it depends on: the fascia board it is fixed to, the brackets that carry its weight, the outlets and the downpipe. A gutter in any material fails quickly if it hangs from a rotten board or from brackets spaced too far apart, so a material decision made without looking at the fixings is only half a decision.
Published lifespans are thin. The one figure given here is for uPVC, and it comes from a retailer rather than from a body that tests gutters. The sections below say so wherever it matters. If a salesperson quotes you a lifespan for aluminium or cast iron, ask where it comes from and what installation it assumes.
The materials side by side
| Material | What it is | How it is joined | Where it fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| uPVC | Moulded plastic | Lengths clip together with rubber seals | Modern and replacement runs |
| Aluminium | Formed metal sheet, painted or coated | Joined sections, or seamless gutters formed to length | Replacement runs where a metal look is wanted |
| Cast iron | Cast metal, painted | Bolted joints with sealant | Period houses and like-for-like repairs |
| Cast aluminium | Cast metal, with a coated finish | Bolted joints with sealant | Period-style profiles in a different metal |
Read the table as a guide to the questions to ask, not as a ranking. The joining method is the column to study first, because a gutter leaks at its joints far more readily than through its body. A run with fewer joints has fewer places to fail, and a joint that depends on a rubber seal or a bead of sealant is only as sound as that seal or sealant. Material also shapes what a repair looks like. A cracked uPVC length is cut out and replaced with a new one. A split in a metal run may be patched, bolted or replaced, depending on where it sits and how far the damage runs. The survey looks at the whole length before anyone says which route applies.
Terms in a gutter quote
- Seamless guttersFormed to length on site, joined only at corners
- BracketThe fixing that carries the gutter's weight
- OutletThe opening where water leaves for the downpipe
- Stop endThe cap closing off a run
uPVC: what it does well and where it lets you down
uPVC is a moulded plastic. It does not rust, and a long run puts modest load on the fascia board. The lengths and fittings clip together, and a replacement section or fitting is easy to match to an existing system because the profiles are made in standard shapes. That makes it a straightforward material to repair as well as to install.
The weakness sits at the joints and fittings. Each clip joint relies on a rubber seal, and a seal that has dried or shifted lets water drip out at the join, which shows as a dark streak on the fascia or wall below. Plastic also expands and contracts with temperature, so a run that is fixed too tightly can pull a joint apart. Brackets are plastic too, and a bracket that has become brittle will let a length drop.
On lifespan there is one figure, for uPVC. A retailer selling uPVC fascia boards puts it this way: when installed correctly, they "can typically maintain reliable performance for between 20 and 40 years". That is a retailer's estimate, it is about uPVC roofline products, and it depends on installation. It is not a guarantee and it is not an independent test, so treat it as the sort of range you might expect rather than a promise for any particular house.
A replacement in uPVC needs the downpipes and fittings to match the run, because profiles from different makers do not always clip together. A mixed system is possible with adaptors, but each adaptor is one more joint to seal, and a survey of the existing run shows which fittings can stay and which have to go. Gutters with a stained or cracked outlet, or a hopper that has split, are better replaced as a set than patched one fitting at a time. White, black, grey and brown uPVC are all made, and colour changes only how the house looks.
Aluminium: seamless gutters and a coated finish
Aluminium guttering is formed from metal sheet and finished in a coating, so it keeps its colour without repainting if the coating holds. It is stiffer than plastic, which means a long run holds its line between brackets, and it can be shaped into profiles that thin plastic cannot match, including square and half-round sections.
The feature that sets it apart is seamless gutters. Instead of clipping standard lengths together, that system forms the gutter from a coil on site, so a single run can pass along a whole wall of the house with joints only at corners and outlets. Fewer joints mean fewer seals to age, which answers the weakness described above for plastic. The trade-off is that the run is made for one house on the day, so a damaged section is repaired or replaced as a run rather than swapped like a clip-in length.
Metal and plastic expand differently, and a metal run that is cut and joined badly can fail at its joints as surely as a plastic one. The material does not do the work alone: the corners, the sealant, the fall and the spacing of brackets still decide the result. No lifespan for aluminium has been sourced here, so a figure offered by an installer should come with the name of its maker or the document it is taken from.
Seamless gutters still need a sound fascia board to hang from. If the board behind is soft, the brackets will pull out of it whichever material is hanging from them, and the fascia has to be dealt with first. Our guide to fascias and soffits explains what that board does and what to check.
Joints and fixings
uPVC
- Clip joints with seals
- No rust to treat
- Easy fittings
Aluminium
- Seamless gutters
- Stiffer between brackets
- Coated finish
Cast iron and cast aluminium on older houses
Cast gutters are made in short lengths and bolted together with sealant at each joint. Cast iron needs paint to protect it from rust, and a neglected run shows rust bloom and flaking at the joints before it shows holes. Cast aluminium does not rust in the same way and is lighter, and it is made in profiles that echo the old iron ones, which is why it is chosen for period-style replacements.
On an older house the material can be part of how the building looks. In a conservation area or on a listed home, changing from cast iron to a different material is a question for the council, not a decision for the roofer or the owner. Our page on cast iron guttering covers repair, repainting and the consent question in more detail.
Cast gutters need a strong fixing. Fascia boards on older houses can be thin, and the brackets may bolt through to the rafter ends instead. A survey looks at what the gutter is fixed to before the material is chosen, since a cast run hung from a board that cannot carry it will not stay up. Joints are the other thing to look at on a cast run. Each bolted joint is sealed with sealant, and an old joint that has split open drips at a spot you can trace by the stain beneath it. Re-sealing a joint is a smaller job than replacing a length, but it only works if the iron beside it is sound.
What decides the price, and how to compare quotes
The only sourced total for gutter replacement is MyJobQuote's: the average gutter replacement cost in the UK is around £1,000 to £1,600 (its page of 20 October 2026, which states no VAT basis). The average is not broken down by material, so it cannot tell you what plastic costs against aluminium, and nothing here should be read as a price for either. What moves a figure is the length of the run, the number of corners and outlets, the height of the eaves and whether the board behind needs work.
The written quote follows a survey and gives one total, so the comparison to make is between like and like. When you hold two quotes side by side, check that both name the material, the length of run being replaced, the number of downpipes and what is being done about the fascia. A quote that covers new gutters on a rotten fascia and one that covers gutters and a new board are not the same job, whatever the totals say. Ask too whether the figure covers taking the old guttering away, since a run left in place is a different job from one removed. Photos of the existing gutters, sent on WhatsApp, give a first idea of the run, though the written price only comes after the survey.
Scaffolding on the pavement or road needs a highway licence from the county council; we arrange the licence with our scaffolder. For a wider sourced look at what replacement costs, see the gutter replacement cost guide, and for the wider picture of the roofline, the guttering, soffits and fascias hub.
Check these in any gutter quote
- The material and the profile being fitted
- The length of run and the number of outlets
- How many downpipes are replaced
- What is being done about the fascia board
- Whether old brackets are renewed


