The short answer
Tell your neighbour and your insurer what happened, photograph the damage, and let each insurer deal with its own side. Fault is for the insurers to weigh, and for solicitors or a court if they disagree, not for a roofer to rule on. The Party Wall etc. Act 1996 applies only to work on or beside a shared wall.
The first hours: people, photographs, a word with the neighbour
Check first that nobody is hurt, and keep people away from anything that could still fall. A tile that has already come off may be followed by others, and a chimney pot that has shifted can drop without warning. If a neighbour's car, greenhouse or conservatory has been hit, tell them face to face at the earliest moment, and say you are sorry.
Then record what happened:
- Photograph the damage on your side and, if the neighbour agrees, on theirs, before anything is moved.
- Note the date, the time and the weather, and which part of your roof the debris came from.
- Swap names and phone numbers, and the name of each other's insurer.
- Tell your own insurer, and let the neighbour tell theirs.
A temporary cover on your roof stops more material falling, and our page on making a roof safe explains what a make-safe involves. Until it is in place, ask everyone in both households, young and old, to stay clear of the shared boundary.
Who pays: insurers first, not a roofer
Your neighbour can claim on their own policy, and their insurer may then look to yours. They can also claim against you directly. Responsibility depends on facts such as the cause of the damage and the condition of the roof, and the insurers weigh those. Where they cannot agree, it passes to solicitors or a court, and a roofer is not the person to say who is at fault.
A building policy can include cover for damage to other people's property, but the wording varies, so ask your insurer what yours says. The Ombudsman's working definition runs: "usually involves violent winds, usually with rain, hail or snow". The insurers will want to know what the weather did on the day.
A roofer's survey records the state of your roof and what the repair involves. It is evidence of condition, not an opinion on liability. Do not agree to pay anything, or say whose fault it was, before you have spoken to your insurer. Our storm damage and home insurance page shows how a claim and the repair go hand in hand.
Where the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 comes in
That Act deals with planned building work, not with who pays for damage. It reaches a roof repair only when the work involves a wall or structure shared with the neighbour. Two cases named in the Act are cutting away a chimney breast, jamb or flue that projects from a party wall, and cutting into an adjoining owner's wall "to insert a flashing or other weather-proofing".
Whoever owns the building and is having the work done sends the notice. The Act sets the lead times. For work to a party structure: "at least two months before the date on which the proposed work will begin". For a new wall at the boundary: "at least one month before he intends the building work to start". An adjoining owner may consent in writing and so allow an earlier start. Silence is treated as dissent: with no consent "within the period of fourteen days", a dispute is taken to exist. GOV.UK says: "You cannot assume that no response means they agree to the works."
If the neighbour objects, the Act sets up a procedure with a surveyor, and it does not give them a veto. Questions about party walls go to a party wall surveyor, not to building control.
Repairing a roof that sits against a neighbour's
Some repairs need the neighbour's say. A ladder, a tower or a scaffold may have to stand on their drive or in their garden, and flashing on a shared chimney or a party wall may be caught by the Act. Ask early, explain what is needed and when work will begin, and keep the conversation friendly: the roof will be easier to repair with their cooperation. If their house has also been damaged, offer to share what you learn from the survey about the cause, so that both insurers work from the same account of what happened to the roof.
Once the roof is covered, the permanent work follows a survey. We examine the whole of your roof, down to the junctions with the house next door, and name anything else we notice in plain words. A single written price covers the lot, and our temporary to permanent roof repair page explains how the stages follow each other.
The wider range of urgent roof problems sits in the emergency roof repairs hub.


