Why the first visit does not finish the job
A make-safe visit has a narrow purpose. Somebody has come out in poor weather, with limited light and a roof that is wet and slippery, to stop water entering and to remove the danger of anything falling. The work done under those conditions is chosen for speed and for staying put through the next few days. It is not chosen for the long term, and it is not meant to be.
That is why the roof is not finished when the sheet is on. The cause of the damage is still there: a broken tile, a torn flashing, a lifted ridge, a split in a flat roof. The covering that keeps the rain out is wearing as soon as it goes up, since sun, wind and rain all act on it. Our guide to making a roof safe describes the methods and what each can and cannot do.
It helps to think of the whole thing as two contracts of work with a gap between them. The first is the temporary cover. The second is the permanent repair, planned with a survey, priced as a single written total and scheduled for conditions that suit the job. The sooner you move from one to the other, the shorter the time the temporary cover has to hold.
Myth
Once a tarpaulin is on, the roof is dealt with.
Fact
Sheeting holds the weather off for now; the fault underneath stays until the permanent repair.
The survey is where the permanent repair starts
A survey covers every slope, in daylight and in the dry, with the access to see it properly. The damage you rang about is the starting point, and the survey does not stop there. It follows the slope either side, the ridge and the verges, the flashings at the chimney and the walls, the valleys and the gutters. It looks at the underlay and the battens wherever the covering has been lifted. You are told what was found, other faults included.
Damage can spread beyond the visible fault. A tile that has slid may have broken the one beneath it. Leaks around a flashing can soak a batten and leave it soft. Insulation that has absorbed water may hold it against the timbers long after the rain has stopped. These are the kinds of finding that decide whether the permanent repair is a small job or a larger one, and none of them is visible from the pavement.
A survey also settles what the lasting repair needs in practical terms. It says how much of the covering has to come off, what has to be replaced, whether the access is good enough from a ladder or needs scaffold, and how the work should be sequenced. The quote that follows is built on those answers. A figure given without a survey rests on guesses.
What the survey looks at
- The damaged area and the slopes either side
- Ridge, hip and verge fixings
- Flashings at chimneys, walls and roof windows
- Underlay and battens where the covering is open
- Gutters, fascias and downpipes below the damage
Matching the materials
A permanent repair puts the roof back to a covering that works as one. That means finding replacement tiles, slates or membrane that suit what is there. A clay plain tile, a concrete interlocking tile, a pantile and a natural slate each have a different size, profile, weight and fixing method, and a replacement from a different family may not sit properly beside the old. Colour and weathering matter to the look, but fit and fixing matter first.
Pantiles show why the product sheet matters. Sandtoft's clay Old English Pantile is listed with a minimum pitch of 30°, with a headlap of 75 mm and a 290 mm fixed gauge, while Marley lists 15° for its Lincoln clay pantile and 25° for its concrete Anglia pantile. Pantiles come in clay and in concrete, and "Canterbury" and "Anglia" are Marley product names, not places. If the replacement is not the same product, those numbers decide whether it can be laid at all on a given roof.
Where the old covering is no longer made, the survey considers a salvaged match, or a different product that suits the pitch and the battens, and says plainly what the difference will look like. Where a flashing is involved, the lead code comes from the specification for that detail. The aim is a repair that sheds water, not one that only looks right from the road.
One written price for the permanent repair
After the survey, the permanent repair is priced as a single written total. The quote describes the work in plain words: the covering to be removed and what goes back, the parts being replaced, the flashings and ridge, and whether scaffold is needed. It is not a list of separate charges, and it is not a number spoken on the phone. Any scaffold the job needs sits within the same quote.
Published figures give a sense of scale, though they cannot tell you your own price. Which? Trusted Traders price a repair covering up to six tiles that are broken or missing at £75 to £400 and a new ridge tile at £80 to £300, excluding VAT, in November 2025. MyJobQuote says a roof repair costs around £650 on average in 2026 (page updated 6 October 2026), and gives no VAT basis. Those are general averages for repairs that do not need much access, and a permanent repair after a storm may sit well outside them.
Read a quote for what it covers as well as the total at the bottom. Check that the covering is named, that the work at the ridge, verges and flashings is described, and that you know what happens to the old materials. Our guide to emergency roof repair costs sets out the published ranges, with their dates, in more detail.
Make-safe visit against permanent repair
Make-safe visit
- Done in poor weather
- Keeps weather out
- Limited look at the roof
- Wears quickly
Permanent repair
- Planned after a survey
- Fixes the cause
- Matching materials
- One written total
Scaffold, licences and access
Some permanent repairs can be done from a ladder, but many cannot. A chimney, a high ridge or a long run of verge may need scaffold to let a roofer work with both hands and a safe place to stand. Scaffold also lets old materials come down and new ones go up without a person carrying them across a roof.
Scaffolding on the pavement or road needs a highway licence from the county council, and we arrange the licence with our scaffolder. The law behind this is the Highways Act 1980, which says that nobody may "erect or retain on or over a highway any scaffolding or other structure which obstructs the highway" without one. The licence has to be in place before the scaffold goes up, so a permanent repair that depends on scaffold is planned around it rather than rushed on the day of the survey.
Scaffold on a house set back from the road, on private land, is not a highway matter in the same way, though a boundary with a neighbour can raise other questions. The survey sees how the job can be reached, and the written quote reflects it. If the access is poor, a temporary cover may have to stay on a little longer, which is one reason for checking it regularly from the ground.
Consents and checks before the lasting repair
Most small repairs need no application, but larger ones raise questions that are better answered before the work starts. The Planning Portal says a building regulations application is not normally needed for re-roofing where the work affects "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" and "Less than 50 per cent of the roof is affected". A repair that strips a large part of the roof, or a whole slope, can fall outside that, and a covering that is "15 per cent or more" heavier, as the Planning Portal puts it, needs approval. We check the route with the council's building control team before the work starts.
Heritage can matter too. A listed home needs listed building consent for changes that affect its character, a conservation area can carry an Article 4 direction, and the council is the body to ask. Inside the Broads, planning for the part of a property within the Authority's executive area goes to the Broads Authority, so check the address.
Two other rules deserve a mention. Damaging or destroying a bat roost is an offence whatever the intent, and GOV.UK lists "repairing or replacing a roof" as work that can need a bat licence, so if bats are known or suspected, say so before any work. And sheeting on an older building could be asbestos cement: HSE says "If the building was built or refurbished before 2000, assume that there is asbestos in it." Under CDM 2015, a homeowner's client duties pass to the contractor.
Signing for the work, and your cancellation rights
The permanent repair is a contract in its own right, so the usual consumer protections apply. A contract signed at your home following a survey carries a 14-day cancellation period, and the regulations say it "ends at the end of 14 days after the day on which the contract is entered into". Work begins inside that period only when you request it in writing. Such a request does not take the 14 days away, though you may owe payment for work already done.
The first visit was different. Regulation 28(1)(e) of the Consumer Contracts Regulations removes the right to cancel where "the consumer has specifically requested a visit from the trader for the purpose of carrying out urgent repairs or maintenance". If you rang because water was coming in, that visit was one you asked for. The later contract, agreed after the survey, is not part of it, and our page on urgent repairs and cancellation rights sets the distinction out.
If an insurance claim is involved, keep the photographs and the dates, and read what the insurer will pay for before you sign. Our page on storm damage and home insurance covers the steps. The insurer decides what a claim returns, under the policy terms, and no roofer can forecast it.


