The short answer
Foam sprayed between the rafters fills the space beside each timber and sets against the roof covering above. It hides the wood, so the structure cannot be fully checked, and it can remove the air gap that a cold roof relies on. Removal frees each rafter in turn.
How foam sits against the rafters
Rafters are the sloping beams that support the battens and the covering above. Between each pair is an empty channel, and the foam is sprayed into it from the loft side, expanding to fill the channel and bond to the timber on both sides and to the underlay or covering above.
Some installers spray just to the depth of the rafter, leaving the face of the timber showing. Others carry on past it, so a continuous layer runs across the rafter faces as well. Each layout hides a different amount of wood, and knowing which one you have is a sensible first question for any surveyor.
RICS puts the consequence plainly: "If the timber roof structure is covered with spray foam it cannot be fully seen or inspected". Rafters that look fine at the edges of the foam may be damp, soft or marked further in, and there is no way of knowing without cutting a window through the foam to look.
Open-cell, closed-cell and the timber
The two foam types behave differently beside wood. EST says of closed-cell foam that "Its main drawback is that it doesn't let moisture pass through it easily." Of the rot danger, EST says "this risk should be much lower with open-cell foam", which is a statement about risk and not a guarantee, so open-cell foam is no promise that the timber is sound.
The reason it matters is that rafters can take on moisture from inside the house, from small leaks at the covering or from condensation. Wood that stays damp for long can soften. Moisture that is shut in behind closed-cell foam may find it harder to dry out. Our page on open-cell and closed-cell spray foam sets the two side by side.
Telling them apart can be done from the loft: open-cell foam feels soft and springy when pressed, while closed-cell foam is firm and dense. A surveyor can confirm which you have, and that identification shapes how removal is done and what tools the work calls for. Do not press hard or cut into the foam yourself, since you cannot see what lies behind it.
Myth
Open-cell foam means the rafters are safe.
Fact
EST says only that rot risk should be much lower with open-cell foam.
The ventilation gap
A cold roof is built with a ventilated gap above the insulation, so that air can enter at the eaves and leave at the ridge. CNC Building Control's guide says of cold roofs: "Ventilation is required for these roofs." Marley gives eaves openings of 25mm for pitches of 15° or less and 10mm above 15° for a cold roof under high-resistance underlay.
Foam pressed hard against the underside of the covering closes that gap. Some installers describe the foam as turning the roof into a warm roof instead, in which the foam itself is the insulation and no ventilation is expected, and CNC's guide says "No ventilation is required for these roofs." Whether that suits a roof originally built to be ventilated is a question for a specialist surveyor. DESNZ advises that anyone deciding what to do about foam should first speak to a specialist surveyor.
The spray foam removal hub explains the wider picture of options, and our page on how spray foam is removed goes through each stage of the work, so you can judge how long it might take on your roof.
Removing foam from between the rafters
Taking foam out of rafter channels is slow, careful work: each channel is cleared by cutting and scraping the foam off the timber sides and off the underside of the covering, working along the slope. Open-cell foam tears away in lumps. Closed-cell foam needs more cutting and the timber needs protecting from the tool.
Once the channels are bare, the rafters are inspected, the underlay is checked and new insulation is fitted, with the air path at the eaves kept open where the roof was built to breathe. Rotten or soft rafter sections can be repaired by fixing a new length of timber alongside the old, a method called sistering. Our survey looks at the whole roof, covering included, and what we find is explained in plain words. Approved Document L may also apply to the new insulation. Table 4.3 gives 0.35 as a threshold and 0.16 as the improved figure, so ask building control what applies to your roof.


