Call 01493 277103

Spray foam removal

Open-Cell or Closed-Cell Spray Foam?

Spray foam in a roof is either open-cell or closed-cell, and the two behave differently where moisture is concerned. This guide sets out what each one is, what the Energy Saving Trust says about them and why the difference matters for the timber above your head.

Get a written quote

Call 01493 277103WhatsApp us

A bungalow roof with a hole and broken ridge tiles after a storm

Two foams that look alike from a distance

Spray foam insulation is two chemicals mixed at the nozzle, which expand and set on the surface they are sprayed onto. The result is a mass of tiny cells. In closed-cell foam the cells are sealed bubbles packed tightly together, and the foam sets hard. In open-cell foam the cells are connected to one another, and the foam stays soft and spongy. From the loft hatch, a sprayed layer of either kind looks like a grey, cream or yellowish crust stuck to the underside of the roof.

The differences begin with how they are made and carry through to how they behave in a roof. A closed-cell foam is compact. It is hard to dent with a thumb, and it adds stiffness to what it is stuck to. An open-cell foam is light, and a thumb pushes into it easily. Both go on wet, so both fill awkward corners and bond to timber, felt and the back of the covering, which is what makes them popular with installers and difficult for anyone who later has to deal with them.

For a homeowner, the first question is therefore a plain one: which of the two is in the loft? Surveys, lender questions and removal quotes all depend on the answer, and some owners do not know it, because the work was done for a previous owner. The sections below say how the answer matters and how a survey establishes it.

What the Energy Saving Trust says about moisture

The Energy Saving Trust (last updated 5 November 2026) is the clearest source on how the two foams treat moisture. The Trust's line on closed-cell foam reads: "Its main drawback is that it doesn't let moisture pass through it easily." The Trust is describing a property of the material, and it does not say that closed-cell foam causes any particular fault. It says the foam does not pass moisture through readily, and a roof is a place where moisture matters.

On the other kind, the same page deals with the question of rot: "this risk should be much lower with open-cell foam". That sentence follows a discussion of the risk of timber rot where moisture is trapped behind insulation. The Trust puts the risk as much lower, which is not the same as none.

Read together, the two lines draw a distinction and stop short of a verdict. Closed-cell foam does not let moisture pass through it easily. The rot risk should be much lower with open-cell foam. What either means for a particular roof depends on the covering, the underlay, the ventilation and the state of the timber, none of which the foam alone decides. A well-kept covering and sound flashings keep rain out of the roof in the first place, and that matters more than the label on the foam beneath.

What the Trust says

Closed-cell

  • Dense, rigid
  • Moisture passes poorly
  • Hard to inspect behind

Open-cell

  • Light, spongy
  • Rot risk much lower
  • Still hides the timber

Why the timber is the point

A roof's timber stays sound while it stays dry. Rafters and battens in a normal cold roof sit in ventilated air and can dry out after a damp spell. Foam sprayed straight beneath the covering changes that arrangement, because the timber is now wrapped in a layer that either lets little moisture through or lets it through but holds it, depending on the type. If a slipped tile or a defective flashing lets rain in, the water has a different path to follow and a different way of drying.

The other problem is inspection. The surveyors' body RICS says: "If the timber roof structure is covered with spray foam it cannot be fully seen or inspected". That applies to both types. An owner cannot look at the rafters in the usual way, and a surveyor cannot either, so a problem can build up out of sight. Our guide to timber that has gone bad beneath the foam goes into what shows up when it is cut away.

None of this means the roof is failing. A roof with foam on it can be perfectly sound, and only a survey will tell you. Taken together, the Trust's wording and the RICS line are a prompt to ask, and to keep the roof covering in good order, because the foam is no substitute for a covering that keeps the rain out.

Telling which one you have

Pressing the foam is the quickest check. Closed-cell foam is firm and resists a thumb. Open-cell foam is soft, a little like a sponge or a dense cushion, and it can be pushed in. A third check is whether the foam is sprayed against the rafters and the underside of the roof covering, or between rafters only, which tells you something about how much of the timber is covered. None of these checks replaces an inspection, because foam is sometimes layered, with one type over another, and a thumb test only tells you about the surface.

The paperwork may help. If the foam was installed for a previous owner, there may be a certificate, an invoice or a product data sheet that names the product, and a lender or a conveyancer may ask for it. If there is nothing, a surveyor can identify the foam, measure how deep it is and see how it sits against the timber.

A photo of the foam sent to our WhatsApp number is a reasonable first step if you are unsure what you have, and the survey is where it is settled. Take it from the hatch without stepping off the joists and without cutting into the foam, since a cut into hard foam can release dust, and treat any loft as a place to move carefully.

Clues to which foam you have

  • Firm and hard to dent suggests closed-cell
  • Soft and spongy suggests open-cell
  • Look for an installer's certificate or invoice
  • Note how deep the foam is and where it sits
  • Ask a surveyor to confirm the type

Mortgages and sales: do the two types differ?

The published wording on lending talks about spray foam in general, not about one type. In a press release of 3 March 2023, RICS reported "concern within specific sectors of the lending market, such as equity release mortgages". The Energy Saving Trust adds that having spray foam "doesn't automatically prevent you from getting a mortgage, but some lenders may ask for extra checks". A DESNZ policy paper published on 22 October 2026 says: "Many mortgage providers are open to lending on properties with spray foam, subject to their own requirements."

So the type is a fact a lender may ask about, and it is a fact worth having at hand. A lender that asks for extra checks is likely to want to know what is in the loft, how it was applied and what condition the timber is in. Our guide to spray foam removal covers what the options are, and the DESNZ paper advises taking advice from a specialist surveyor before making any decision about the foam.

If a sale or remortgage is on the horizon, the order is the same as for any foam problem: ask your lender what it requires, get the foam identified, and then decide whether to leave it or remove it. DESNZ is careful on the point that removal "will not always guarantee that they will still lend". Removal is not offered as a cure for every lender's concern.

Removing open-cell and closed-cell foam

The two foams come off differently. Dense, rigid closed-cell foam is cut into sections and then worked off the timber, and where it is bonded firmly it can resist a scraper. Soft open-cell foam can be pulled away in pieces and then pared back to the wood. Which is easier depends on how well each is stuck down, and on the timber beneath. Our guide to how spray foam is removed follows the stages in order.

The type also shows up in published costs. Checkatrade (July 2026) says removal typically runs between £50 and £75 per m² for open-cell foam. That is the only per square metre figure it gives for a type, and it is a rate, not a total. MyJobQuote (page dated 17 September 2026) gives an average of £40 per m² for removal, without saying which type it means. Neither guide offers a rate for closed-cell foam, so no comparison between the two can be made from published figures.

What the foam is made of is one factor among several in a removal price, alongside the area covered, the depth, access to the loft and what the timber looks like underneath. Our guide to spray foam removal costs sets out the full list. The written quote that follows a survey is one total price for your roof.

Myth

Closed-cell and open-cell foam treat moisture the same way.

Fact

The Energy Saving Trust says closed-cell foam doesn't let moisture pass through it easily.

Questions to ask before you decide anything

Start with the facts you can get without anyone climbing into the loft. When was the foam installed? Who did it, and is there a certificate or a product name? Was it sprayed up against the covering, or between the rafters, or both? Has the roof leaked since? Has a buyer's surveyor or a lender already raised it? The answers do not settle the matter, but they make a survey quicker and a quote more reliable.

Then ask what you want to decide. Leaving the foam in place with a survey on file is one option. Removal is another. A third is to do nothing now and revisit the question if you sell or remortgage. On mortgages, the Trust's wording is that foam "doesn't automatically prevent you from getting a mortgage", so a lender's own policy is the thing to find out first.

Whichever way you lean, speak to a specialist surveyor before making any decision about the foam, as DESNZ advises. A cold call offering to sell or remove foam is not the place to start: the same paper notes that the growth of the removals sector has led to an increase in cold calls and unsolicited offers. The roof is surveyed end to end before any quote, the findings come to you plainly, and the price is one written total.

Questions and answers

What is the difference between open-cell and closed-cell spray foam?

Closed-cell foam is hard and compact, with sealed cells, and in the Energy Saving Trust's words it "doesn't let moisture pass through it easily". Open-cell foam is light and yielding, and the Trust puts the risk of rot as "much lower" with it. Both types can bond to timber and hide it from inspection.

Does open-cell foam have no risk of rot?

No. The Energy Saving Trust says the risk should be much lower with open-cell foam, which is not the same as none. With either type, RICS says a covered timber roof structure "cannot be fully seen or inspected". A survey is the way to find out what condition the wood is in.

How can I tell which kind I have in my loft?

Closed-cell foam is firm and hard to dent, while open-cell foam is soft and spongy, but foam can be layered, so a thumb test is only a clue. An installer's certificate or invoice may name the product. A survey identifies the type and shows how deep it is and how it sits against the timber.

Does the type of foam matter to a mortgage lender?

Published wording on lending refers to spray foam in general. DESNZ says: "Many mortgage providers are open to lending on properties with spray foam, subject to their own requirements." The Energy Saving Trust adds that "some lenders may ask for extra checks". Ask your own lender what it requires, and say which type you have.

Get a written quote

Tell us about your roof

Hand dressing a lead ridge roll with a wooden bossing stick

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing

Call WhatsApp Written quote